---

name: diorama description: Use when building a pixel diorama in Three.js — one-prompt autonomous builds with staged systems, detailed props, real animation, and social/service choreography. version: 3.8.0 author: Nehal Kanak (sloemo) license: MIT platforms: [linux, macos, windows]

Diorama

A diorama is a tiny staged scene on a slab: a locked three-quarter camera, a flat cut-out against white, a palette-snapped pixel grid with an ink contour, and toy-scale people with real joint animation. Any subject works (pool, market, kitchen, bank job, launch pad, aquarium). The slab and the cast stay; the props change.

This file is the whole guide. It carries no external reference documents: everything needed to build a diorama is here, plus copy-in modules and a design sheet template in templates/.

Read Research Before You Model, One Prompt, One Build, The Look Contract, The Detail Bar, The Animation Bar and Pipeline first. Then read the sections for the systems you are actually building; the rest is reference. Do not spend the first pass reading every vehicle or water note for a kitchen scene.

Fast path by scene

If the commission is...	Read next, in this order
market, food truck, bakery, cafe, shop, laundromat	Cast → Clothed Cast: Heads, Layers, Hands → Service And Queue → Machine Grammar → Carrying, Loading And Mounting → Verification
heist, defence, combat	Detail Bar → Tool/Tower recipes → System And Combat Animation → Combat Readability → Verification
creature battle, game scene, anime/movie fight	Research Before You Model → Field Notes: Two-Creature Combat → Creature Anatomy → System And Combat Animation → Combat Readability → Verification
aquarium, pool, harbour	Cast → base rig → Water templates → Vehicles (boat) → Effects → Verification
station, airport, hotel, transit	Service And Queue → Vehicles → Crowd Variation → Verification
stage, festival, parade	Cast → Secondary Motion → Crowd Variation → System Grammar → Verification
farm, garden, nature	Creature Anatomy → Ambient Loops → Effects → Verification

The universal shape still applies: place + repeated ritual + interruption + consequence. The fast path only decides which reference notes to read first.

When to Use

• "Make a small diorama / miniature scene / pixel scene of X"
• A clip or still shows a flat cut-out scene with chunky pixels and little people, and the ask is to match that look
• An existing 3D scene needs the pixel-art presentation (palette, dither, ink, locked angle) rather than a smooth render
• The figures need believable motion: walking, climbing into a car, sitting, swimming, diving, and it has to survive close inspection
• The ask is for a staged diorama, not a model: several systems, a cast, a goal or boss, and a loop that can be frozen at any second
• The user gives only one line ("a bakery at closing", "a lighthouse under siege"); this skill is designed to turn that into a complete commission without an interview

Don't use for full-resolution product renders, photoreal scenes, or anything that needs free orbit controls.

Research Before You Model

Four lookups come before the first mesh: the subject by frames, the asset libraries, the motion itself, and the capture loop. Skipping them is how a build ends up with a plausible silhouette that matches nothing and animation that reads as generic. Budget for them, they are usually faster than the modelling they save.

Question the research answers	Where it lands
what does it look like, exactly	refs/<subject>/*.png contact sheets
what does it do, in what order, how fast	refs/SOURCES.md + the beat table
does a rig or clip already exist	CREDITS.md + assets/
is it actually right on screen	qa/ captures, compared to the sheets

1. The subject, by frames

Find the real thing moving, not stills. For games, anime, sport or machinery the footage is the specification: it settles what the shape is, where the motion starts, how long each stage lasts and what colour it is at each step.

yt-dlp --flat-playlist --print "%(id)s | %(title)s | %(duration)s" "ytsearch6:<subject> animation"
yt-dlp --extractor-args "youtube:player_client=ios,android" -f 18 -o "refs/clip.%(ext)s" <id>
ffmpeg -i refs/clip.mp4 -vf "fps=8,scale=300:-1,tile=6x4" refs/sheet-%02d.png

Read the contact sheets with vision, then write the grammar down in words before touching geometry: ball leaves the hand on an arc, opens with a white burst, the creature springs out at full size, the ball snaps shut and returns. A paragraph like that is the acceptance test for the effect you are about to build.

Rules that come out of doing this repeatedly:

• Prefer game footage over fan animation for game subjects; the game is the canonical grammar, and fan cuts are already an interpretation.
• Prefer one clean clip sampled densely over ten clips sampled sparsely. Twelve frames a second on a 4 second send-out shows the whole sequence.
• Keep the sheets in refs/<subject>/ next to the build so the next person can see what you were matching, and so QA has an image to compare against.

2. Model sourcing: check the libraries before you build

Hand-building a creature from primitives is the last option, not the first. A rigged download with real deformation and usable clips beats four hundred lines of spheres the moment the camera comes within a metre. Search first, and keep a record of what you searched.

The ladder. Every hero asset walks down it in order.

1. Already on disk. The user's folder often ships a tools/, assets/ or model/ directory with GLBs in it. List it before anything else.
2. A CC0 pack covers it. Import it. No attribution, no negotiation.
3. A CC-BY model covers it and the page can carry a credit line. Import it, credit it, done.
4. Nothing fits the silhouette and the shape has to be exact. Hand-build it against the reference frames, and say in the log that you searched.
5. Never: ripped game assets, Models Resource / Spriters Resource downloads used as geometry, "editorial use only", NC, ND, or anything with no stated licence. Those are hard stops; ask the user instead of guessing.

Creatures, characters and rigs

Source	Licence	What is actually there	How to search
Quaternius	CC0	hundreds of low-poly creatures, characters, nature, buildings; the Universal Animation Library is 120+ clips	browse quaternius.com/packs, grab the pack GLB
KayKit / Kay Lousberg	CC0	adventurers, skeletons, dungeon and RPG packs, rigged and animated	itch page, per-pack zip
Poly Pizza	CC0 or CC-BY	10,000+ low-poly props, creatures, vehicles; GLB/OBJ, no login	search by noun, read the badge on each card
Kenney	CC0	kits for props, vehicles, characters, UI, audio	category browse
Sketchfab	per model	the long tail: specific machines, animals, buildings	filter Downloadable + CC0/CC-BY before looking at anything
Smithsonian 3D	CC0	scanned real objects, fossils, artefacts, vehicles	search, check the licence note under the download
NASA 3D Resources	public domain	spacecraft, rovers, terrain, helmets	browse by category
glTF Sample Assets	per model, mostly CC-BY 4.0	canonical rigged test models (CesiumMan, Fox, BrainStem)	read LICENSES/ before use
Objaverse	mixed, per object	800k research objects, good for odd props	verify the per-object licence, most are not clean
Meshy, Tripo, user-supplied	user owns the output	anything the pack libraries do not have, generated from the reference	export GLB, keep the prompt in CREDITS.md

Animation clips (motion is usually harder to hand-key than shape is to model)

Source	Licence	Notes
Quaternius Universal Animation Library	CC0	120+ humanoid clips, retargetable, best first stop
Mixamo	free with an Adobe account	thousands of humanoid clips + characters; check current Adobe terms, retarget in Blender or three.js
Rokoko Motion Library	150 free clips, paid beyond	mocap quality, good for weight and follow-through
CMU Graphics Lab Motion Capture	free for research and commercial use with credit	raw BVH, huge, needs cleanup
Sketchfab animated models	per model	often ships with an idle/walk/attack set
Godot4 Open Animation Libraries	CC0	Mixamo clips rebaked as Godot .bin/GLB banks, already retargeted; jwelchgames/Godot4-MixamoLibraries is the other mirror

Props, environments, textures, light

Source	Licence	Notes
Poly Haven	CC0	HDRIs, textures, models; the HDRI set is the fastest way to fix flat lighting
ambientCG	CC0	tiling PBR materials, HDRIs, some models
OpenGameArt	mixed	filter to CC0 / CC-BY; 3D section is thin but has good odd props
madjin/awesome-cc0	index	a maintained list of CC0 sources when the usual four fail

Searching them without a browser. Three of the libraries have open APIs, so a build can check them in a single command and read the licence back:

# Sketchfab: downloadable + CC0 only, name and page printed for each hit
curl -s "https://api.sketchfab.com/v3/search?type=models&downloadable=true&license=cc0&q=dragon&count=24" \
  | python3 -c "import json,sys;[print(r['name'],'|','https://sketchfab.com/models/'+r['uid']) for r in json.load(sys.stdin)['results']]"

# Poly Haven: models, HDRIs, textures (filter by category)
curl -s "https://api.polyhaven.com/assets?t=models"
curl -s "https://api.polyhaven.com/assets?t=hdris&c=studio"

# ambientCG: materials and HDRIs by keyword
curl -s "https://ambientcg.com/api/v2/full_json?type=Material&limit=20&q=concrete" \
  | python3 -c "import json,sys;print([a['assetId'] for a in json.load(sys.stdin)['foundAssets']])"

Poly Pizza, Quaternius, KayKit and Kenney are browsed by search on their own pages; query them with the noun plus the style (low poly dragon, kaykit skeleton), not with a sentence.

Reference only, never geometry: The Spriters Resource, The Models Resource, sakugabooru, game rip archives, Pinterest. Use them to learn the shape and the timing, then build or buy the actual asset.

3. Animation research: how the thing moves

Shape is half the job; the other half is the motion, and it is researched the same way. Search the verb, not the noun.

# the motion itself, canonical first
web_search: "<subject> <move> animation"      # a game doing it
web_search: "<subject> <move> slow motion"    # real footage, for weight
web_search: "<subject> sprite sheet"          # frame-by-frame timing
yt-dlp "ytsearch6:<subject> <move> animation"
ffmpeg -i clip.mp4 -vf "fps=12,scale=320:-1,tile=6x4" refs/move-%02d.png

Read the sheet, then count frames and convert: seconds = frames / fps, and scale to the loop length you are building. That is how a 0.42 s anticipation and a 0.18 s contact become the beat table instead of a guess.

Write four lines per action before animating it:

wind-up   0.00 -> 0.42   weight back, head down, tail still
contact   0.42 -> 0.55   fastest frames, one pose held for two frames
follow    0.55 -> 0.90   overshoot, then settle
recover   0.90 -> 1.30   back to idle

Every attack in the beat sheet needs all four. Missing anticipation is why an effect reads as "it just happens", and missing follow-through is why it reads as "it snaps back".

For rigs, cross-check the reference against a real clip: if the library has a punch, a swipe or a jump that is close, retarget it and offset the acting, rather than keying a pose from scratch.

4. The research log

Every build writes refs/SOURCES.md. It is the proof the searches happened and the reason the next person does not repeat them.

| Question | Searched | Found | Decision |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| what does the send-out look like | yt: "sword shield send out slow motion" | RoUJ_TWvB3g, orb + white burst | matched, timings below |
| hero creature rig | poly.pizza "dragon", quaternius characters | nothing matching the silhouette | hand-built from refs/sendout |
| hit reaction weight | yt: "pokemon take damage animation" | 0.9 s flinch, 1.7 s stagger | HURTS table |

A build with no SOURCES.md has not finished its research step, even if the scene looks right.

5. Prove it with shots

Every beat gets frozen, captured and compared against the reference sheet before the next beat is built. The contact sheet of those captures is the review artifact, not a paragraph describing them.

• Freeze the loop at the beats the reference showed: ?t=<second> in the page, freeze(t) through the debug hook, screenshot the frame element.
• Put the captures in a grid next to the reference frames and read them with vision. Anything that needs a caption to explain is not finished.
• Keep numerical checks alongside the pictures: facing dot products, NaN scans over every geometry, console errors, effect bounding boxes. They catch the failures the eye forgives at 300 px.

One Prompt, One Build

When the user gives a subject in one line, treat it as a commission, not a questionnaire. Make the creative decisions, state them in one short assumption line, and build the whole diorama. Do not stop at a plan, a blockout or a design sheet and wait for approval.

The only reasons to ask are credentials, a destructive action, or a path that would overwrite the user's work. Everything else is a default.

Step 0, before the assumption line

Run the three lookups in Research Before You Model first:

1. Step the real subject into frames and write down its motion grammar.
2. Walk the sourcing ladder for every hero asset (disk, CC0, CC-BY, hand-build), with a CREDITS.md line per import and the search in refs/SOURCES.md.
3. Stand up the capture loop (qa/shoot.mjs, a frozen ?t= frame, a contact sheet) so every beat can be reviewed as a picture.

For an invented subject, spend the same time on reference density instead: find three images that agree on what the place looks like, list the props they share, and build those before any invented detail.

The default commission

Use these unless the prompt explicitly says otherwise:

Knob	Default
Slab	21 x 14 x 0.42 m; 16 x 12 for one room, 24 x 16 for a street, port or launch pad
Loop	46 s at 40 Hz; one readable cycle plus a quiet seam
Palette	64 entries
Systems	4 defences/machines/service stations/attractions; 3 is acceptable, 6 is the ceiling
Cast	4 to 6 roles total, including one disruption; 2 ambient loops
Props / landmarks	2 hero props, 1 landmark, 3 to 6 supporting props
Hero detail	every hero object meets the Detail Bar
Animation	every hero actor has all five layers
Output	index.html, <slug>.html, README.md, DESIGN.md, src/, dist/
Path	<cwd>/<slug>/ unless the user named a folder
Minimum viable	3 systems, 3 roles + 1 disruption, 1 hero prop + 1 landmark, 30 s loop; still passes the bars

State the assumption in one line before coding:

Assumption: market archetype, 46 s loop, 4 service systems, 6 roles plus a late customer, 21 x 14 slab, 64 colours. Say if you want a different scale or genre.

That line is the contract. State it, then continue in the same turn; do not wait for approval. It gives the user a chance to redirect after seeing the assumption, without blocking the build.

Long builds and context

A scene like this runs for hours of agent time and thousands of messages: render loops, one screenshot per beat, one probe per bug. The session will need to compress its context, more than once, and compaction is lossy. Build so that a compact does not cost you the work:

• State lives in files, not in the chat. DESIGN.md, refs/SOURCES.md, CREDITS.md, qa/report.json and the beat table in stage.js must carry every decision. If a fact only exists in a message, it is already gone.
• Write the rule down when you learn it. A fix found at 3 a.m. is worthless if it only exists in the transcript; put it in the skill or a comment next to the code, with the reason.
• Name the shots. qa/frames/<entity>/sheet.png and shots/t-12.40.png are stable handles a post-compact agent can re-read without rerunning anything.
• Re-derive, do not remember. After a compact, re-run frames.mjs and shoot.mjs rather than trusting your summary of what the last frame looked like: the numbers are cheap, and a confident memory of an old build is the most expensive thing in the session.
• Keep one open task list in the repo (a TODO.md or an issue) so the thread that survives compaction is the plan, not the chat.

Reading the prompt

Prompt shape	What to do
one noun ("a bakery")	pick the closest router row; invent the verb, disruption and goal
one sentence ("a lighthouse under siege")	take its nouns and verbs literally; fill the missing cast/systems from the router
a reference image	match its composition, camera side and palette first; keep this skill's detail/animation bars
"like X but Y"	reuse X's structure, replace the subject and the detail anchors; do not copy X's nouns
"make it detailed"	use the full Detail Bar and five animation layers; do not add more systems
"keep it simple"	cut systems and cast, not detail per hero; two rich objects beat six blockouts

A prompt that names only a place is still a commission. Decide what the place does, who arrives, and what goes wrong. State the assumption and build.

The scene router

Pick the closest row. Do not invent a new genre from scratch unless none fit.

If the prompt is...	Systems (3–5)	Cast	Goal / disruption	Detail anchor
defence, siege, castle, base, zombies	4 towers + gate guns	defenders, 4 species, boss	boss reaches the gate	gatehouse
heist, bank, museum, casino	drill, lasers, cameras, getaway	3 crew, guards, manager	vault opens / escape	vault door
market, kitchen, bakery, cafe, food truck, night market	stalls, ovens, prep, pass, dispatch	vendors, cooks, cashier, courier, customers, inspector	closing time / service rush / last bag	counter, hatch or oven
laundromat, workshop, gym, repair shop, arcade	washers, dryers, benches, tools, machine slots, ticket rail	folder, attendant, customer, courier, cat	last load / closing / power cut	machine bank or workbench
launch, factory, port, mine	gantry, press, crane, conveyor	crew, inspector, cargo	launch / ship / lift	gantry
aquarium, pool, harbour, reef	filters, pumps, slides, lights	fish, swimmers, diver, lifeguard	feeding / party / storm	reef or tank
station, airport, bus, hotel	signal, platform, desk, luggage	commuters, guard, porter	last departure	clock
festival, temple, carnival, funeral	stage, rides, altar, procession	performers, crowd, official	climax / storm	big top or altar
farm, garden, safari, nature	irrigation, harvester, weather vane	animals, farmer, crows	harvest / storm	barn
home, shop, library, workshop	rooms, counter, shelves, tools	family, clerk, customer, pet	opening / closing	window
arena, battle, mech, gladiator	traps, weapons, doors, lifts	fighters, champion, beast	champion enters	gate

If none fit, use the universal shape: **place + repeated ritual + interruption

• consequence**. Give it 3 to 5 systems, 4 roles and one goal. A quiet subject still needs a verb: a library needs a closing, a bakery needs a service, a lighthouse needs a sweep that fails.

If the router misses

Do not freeze. Answer four questions about the noun:

1. What does this place produce or repeat? Bread, light, trains, fish, money, quiet, laundry, coffees.
2. Who operates it? Baker, keeper, guard, diver, clerk, mechanic.
3. What interrupts the output? A critic, a storm, a thief, a shutdown, a delivery, a leak, a closing-time crowd.
4. What is the visible consequence? Burnt batch, dark lens, missed train, flooded tank, empty till, closed sign.

Those four answers give you the system, cast, goal and residue. Then use the five beats: normal output → first interruption → escalation → goal contact → residue and seam. No combat required. A deadline, an inspection, a storm or a closing bell is a valid boss.

Worked one-prompt example:

"a tiny bakery at closing time"

• Archetype: market/kitchen. Slab 16 x 12. Loop 42 s.
• Systems: oven, proofing rack, counter, till. Cast: baker, apprentice, last customer, food inspector (the disruption).
• Goal: the inspector reaches the counter before the last loaf is sold.
• Beats: 0 s oven glow and bread out; 8 s first customer; 16 s inspector at the door; 26 s last loaf contested; 34 s sign turns, flour settles, cat sleeps.
• Detail anchors: oven door (hinges, soot, peel), bread rack (trays, crumbs, cloth), counter (ledger, bell, worn edge), inspector's clipboard.
• No towers: use machine grammar for the oven and till; field audit for the oven's heat; death/exit for the inspector's departure.

The autonomous pass

1. Interpret. Pick the archetype; write the assumption line; fill DESIGN.md yourself. Do not ask the user to fill it.
2. Blockout. Grey slab, camera, five beats at 1:1. No palette, no post, no materials. If the beats do not read, restage before adding detail.
3. Presentation. Palette, light, post, ink, dither, camera solve.
4. Set and props. Landmark, two hero props, supporting dressing. Clear the 2 m threshold. No duplicate silhouettes.
5. Cast and detail. Rig the cast; apply the Detail Bar to every hero object. Cut a role before cutting detail per role.
6. Animation and systems. Five layers per hero; tower acquire/fire/impact/ recovery; field ramp/area/affect/decay; machine input/motion/output/residue.
7. Effects and residue. Contact shadows, species deaths, dropped gear, stains, ambient loops, loop seam.
8. QA and package. Detail/animation audit, numbers, 1:1 crops, standalone file://, README and DESIGN.md agreeing.

If time is tight, cut the number of systems or actors, never the detail per hero or the animation layers. Two detailed towers with five layers beat six blockout towers with one fire animation.

Efficiency rules

• One project, one build loop. Scaffold once, then build, shoot and fix in place. Do not rewrite the entry file for a detail that lives in a prop module.
• Build only what the locked camera sees. Spend the polygon and part budget on the +Z face and the top; simplify the back.
• Cut systems before detail. A tight build with two rich towers and five animation layers reads better than six thin towers with one recoil.
• Use the templates. Camera, post, palette, lighting, the cast rig and the detail helpers are already solved; do not re-derive them from prose.
• Shoot known timestamps. Freeze at the five beat times and the five QA frames; do not scrub for a good frame.
• Package last, once. Build the standalone only after the QA frames pass; rebuilding it after every tweak wastes the pass.

One-prompt acceptance

Do not report "done" until all of these are true:

• DESIGN.md exists and matches the build.
• Five beats have timestamps and proof frames.
• Every system has events; every actor has a death, exit or residue.
• Each hero has three detail passes and at least one story detail.
• Each hero actor has idle, locomotion, action, reaction and death/exit.
• Every carry, handoff, load and mount has a contact timestamp and a nine-frame strip; palms are on the prop and boots are on the vehicle.
• A queue serves after arrival, never before; no standing gesture is blended into a walking root.
• No generic sphere burst, floating prop, clipped landmark or beam on a target that has already expired.
• No fixed deck prop, ammo store, tool or crew member moves with a turret, flywheel or machine pivot.
• Standalone opens over file:// with zero console errors.
• The final message gives the path, loop length, system/shot counts and the QA frames, not a request for feedback.

Starting A New Diorama

When the subject is new, the first deliverable is a design sheet, not a scene. With a one-line prompt, fill it from the defaults in One Prompt, One Build and do not ask the user to complete it.

1. Copy templates/DESIGN.md into the project as DESIGN.md.
2. Write the premise as a verb, not a noun. Name the place, the repeated action, who interrupts it, and the payoff.
3. Fill the cast and system sheets. If a role has no action, cut it. If a system has no visible consequence, cut it.
4. Pick five beats and five QA timestamps. A beat without a timestamp is not staged.
5. Block out in grey at the locked camera and shoot the five beats at 1:1. This is a staging check, not a production pass: no palette, no post, no materials. Redesign staging before committing to it.
6. Once the blockout reads, run the production pipeline below. Palette is the first production pass; the grey blockout does not count as one. Detail multiplies a readable blockout; it cannot rescue an unreadable one.

The rest of this file is the recipe for each pass.

The Look Contract

Ten rules. Break one and it stops reading as a diorama.

1. Locked angle. One three-quarter view, no drift, no orbit. Azimuth 45, elevation 33, fov 20.5, target just under the slab centre. When the user says "this angle", it means this one, for the whole loop.
2. Flat cut-out. A slab with no plinth, no soil sides, background null, page white. Everything below the deck plane hides in the overhang at 33 degrees.
3. Palette snap. Every pixel resolves to one entry of a fixed palette. No gradients survive; banding is the material.
4. Ink contour. A luminance-neighbour edge mixes toward warm near-black at about 0.62, suppressed on the outer rim so figures are not haloed.
5. Dither only where tones move. Ordered Bayer gated by local edge contrast. Flat decks stay flat; ramps stipple.
6. Contact shadows, not just cast shadows. A soft radial patch under every figure and prop is what anchors it to the ground at this scale.
7. People read at 30 to 45 px. Faces need eyes, brows, nose, mouth, ears. Bodies need joint fillers so a bend never opens a wedge.
8. Clipped edge. The slab is a window, not a stage: four world-space clip planes sit on its edges and anything driving in or out is cut at the boundary. Nothing ever floats on the white page outside the block.
9. Everything is a pure function of t. No integration that carries state between frames, no Math.random, no drift across the loop.
10. Empty paper. The white page carries no DOM title, caption, HUD or instructions. Put copy on a modelled sign/screen or in the browser title; a label floating on the paper breaks the cut-out.

The Detail Bar

A blockout with a camera is not a diorama. The difference between a demo and a diorama is three passes, and every hero object has to survive all three.

1. Silhouette. At 1:1 the object is recognisable from its outline in about 0.2 seconds, before colour or detail.
2. Construction. The silhouette is explained by visible assemblies: posts, rails, bands, plates, wheels, hinges, ropes, fasteners. A single primitive is a placeholder, not a prop.
3. Story. One detail tells you who used it and what happened: a chipped edge, a trophy skull, a repair strap, a spare bolt, a rag, a tally mark, a spent shell. If the detail could be removed without changing the read, it is greeble, not story.

The numbers below are reference density from The Hollow Toll, a 21 x 14 m slab with four towers, two gate guns, five species, 42 units, one boss, 527 events and 183 shots. Treat them as a calibration target, not a cap.

Element	Minimum visible assemblies	Hero target	Required story detail
Tower	6	25 to 45 parts	crew, ammo, livery, wear
Creature	8	12 to 20 parts; boss 40 to 60	gear, scar, trophy
Prop	5	8 to 15 parts	contents, tool, repair, rag
Landmark	8	30 to 60 parts	one unmistakable silhouette
Death	3 stages	5 to 8 pieces + stain + soul	species-specific debris
Environment	3 scale cues, 3 story props	2 ambient loops	a before/after trace

In a social diorama, read the Death row as Exit: a role-specific departure (turn, walk out, shutter down) with the prop and no debris. The five layers are unchanged; the residue is the changed place, not a stain.

An object can hold two roles. A lighthouse that is also a beam tower gets the landmark budget for its structure plus the machine's moving parts; list both rows in the design sheet. A boss weapon is a separate group: budget 8 to 12 parts for the weapon on top of the body, and say so, or the body will be blamed for a thin haft.

Primitive discipline. No naked box, sphere or cylinder at hero scale. A box gets a chamfer, a frame, plank divisions or a band. A sphere becomes a skull, bale, sack or head with a snout, ties or a neck. A cylinder gets a foot, cap, taper or iron rings. If a shape is still a primitive after the detail pass, it will read as a rock, a blob or a placeholder at 30 to 45 px.

Two to four palette entries per object, plus one accent. More entries turns into noise after the palette snap; fewer turns into a silhouette cut-out. Use value contrast for construction and hue for story.

Detail lives on the camera-facing surfaces. At the locked angle, model the front and the top; simplify the back. A perfect back is wasted geometry. Do not add detail under about 1.5 screen pixels: it aliases into speckle, not craft.

Every prop must touch the ground. Feet, wheels, a base, a contact shadow, a stain. A prop hovering by two centimetres is the single most common "it looks cheap" report. Check the shadow and the lowest vertex, not the group origin.

Every landmark must be the only one of its silhouette. Two skull trees, two red tents or two identical towers read as duplication, not composition. Move, scale or redesign the second one. Check overlap by projecting both bounding boxes to screen: if they merge into one blob, one is invisible detail.

Clear thresholds. Keep at least 2 m of empty ground in front of a gate, portal, spawn mouth or door. No crates, barrels, boulders, bones, vines or rising smoke in that pocket. A grey billboard above an arch reads as a rock flying out of the entrance even when it is transparent.

The Animation Bar

An actor is animated when it has all five of these, not just a walk cycle:

1. Idle / ambient. Breathing, sway, scan, flame, flag, wing settle. Two loops minimum in the environment.
2. Locomotion. Distance-driven walk, run, hop, flap or slither, with feet planted and joints filled.
3. Action. A readable wind-up, contact and recovery: fire, swing, slam, dive, throw, open, build.
4. Reaction. A directional flinch, hit flash, knockback, stagger or squash that recovers to the same pose.
5. Exit / consequence. In a combat diorama, a body-specific collapse plus debris, dropped gear, a ground stain and a brief residue — never a generic sphere burst. In a social diorama, the equivalent is a role-specific exit: turn, walk out with the bag, close the shutter, or sit back down. The scene must show that the actor changed the place.

Background actors need 1, 2 and 5. Hero actors need all five. A tower is an actor too: idle hum, aim, fire, recoil, reload. A service actor's action is order/pay/receive, its reaction is a look-up or step-back, and its exit is the walk-out with the prop. A prop with a moving part (door, flag, wheel, pulley, cauldron) needs its own loop.

Motion is data. Author beats as absolute times or travel distances, then read them at t. Do not hide a state machine inside render-frame conditionals; it will pop on a seek, drift on a loop, and be impossible to screenshot.

Nothing at hero scale is static. A tower that spawns a projectile from its centre without recoil, a boss that stands at a door without touching it, a creature that slides without a step: all read as unfinished, even with good geometry.

Numbers That Make It Read

Knob	Value	Why
Camera	fov 20.5, az 45, elev 33	long lens, near-ortho miniature
Framing	fillX 0.84–0.94, fillY 0.86–0.94	fit margin only: slab plus landmark tops
Subject scale	1.0, or 0.70 for 30% smaller	post-fit camera multiplier; never geometry
Camera distance	solved, 5 to 300	bisection; actual distance = fit / subjectScale
Post buffer	1× CSS; 1.2–1.5× for a small subject; 2× faces	extra detail without resizing the diorama
Palette	64 entries (any N, but the shader array and loop must match)	skin, stone, asphalt, glass, livery, props
Dither	d*(0.0012 + 0.019*gate) + sparkle*0.0012	stipple in ramps only; gate = edge
Ink	smoothstep(0.13,0.34,edge), mix 0.62	outline without scribble
Palette tie-break	secondD-bestD < 0.0005 → lighter	flat surfaces come out flat
Sun	0xfff8ee at 3.3, hemi 0.24, fill 0.46, env 0.18	hard shadows, cool fill
Shadow cam	±13, near 4, far 70, 2048 map, bias -0.00022	tight around the whole slab, no acne
Figure	1.69 m, hip 0.86, head 0.584	toy proportions that read
Car	L 4.4, W 1.86, belt 0.90, roof 1.44	door 1.30, leaf sits between 0.34 and 0.90
Scooter	wheel r 0.26, board 0.30, seat 0.83, bars 1.06	boots and hands land on built surfaces
Loop	41 to 47 s	one robbery beat plus police, and a quiet seam

The table mixes two different kinds of number, and treating them alike is how a new subject comes out wrong.

Invariants. Come from the look itself and hold on every subject: azimuth 45, elevation 33, fov 20.5; one locked camera for the whole loop; palette discipline (every material samples a palette entry, the shader array length equals the palette length); gated dither, ink at 0.13/0.34 mixed 0.62, the palette tie-break; the rig's proportions and joint signs; 2048 shadow map with a frustum tight to the slab; everything a pure function of t.

Calibrated. Measured against one subject and only evidence for it: palette count (64 for the bank job, 66 here), buffer size and renderScale (1×/1.25×/2×), fillX/fillY, subjectScale and the camera size divisor, slab dimensions and deck height, loop length, sun and hemisphere intensities, and every prop dimension in the vehicle and scooter rows. Re-derive these per build: start from the value, then look at a screenshot and change it.

A scene may change any calibrated number if the subject needs it; change the template and DESIGN.md in the same edit and record the reason. A template that silently uses a 2x different sun is worse than no template, because the next reader trusts it.

Pipeline

Each step ends in something you can look at.

1. Palette first. The palette array in palette.js plus a named C map. Every material samples a palette hex, nothing else. Done when a grep for colour literals in materials.js finds only palette names.
2. Frame the slab. Camera constants from templates/camera.js, slab sized so its projected diamond leaves a margin. Done when a grey slab shot has roughly 25 to 40 percent white around it at subjectScale: 1.0; for a smaller subject, apply subjectScale after the fit and expect more paper, not a smaller set.
3. Light it. Sun plus low hemisphere for daylight; the Night, Practicals And Headlights rig for a night scene. Tighten the shadow camera to the slab and call updateProjectionMatrix() after changing the frustum. Done when every figure has a readable contact shadow (crisp by day, a soft pool by night).
4. Post pass. templates/post.js: gamma, grade, ink, gated dither, palette snap, rim dither. Done when a 1:1 crop shows square pixels and a dark contour, and flat pavement shows no speckle.
5. Props. Flat-colour boxes and lathes, no textures, coarse detail. Done when the 1:1 crop reads the object's silhouette without colour.
6. Cast. templates/peopleModel.js (base) or templates/peopleModel-street.js (clothed) rig, one entry per figure with a base pose. Done when isolated portraits show no gaps, no floating parts, knees bending the right way.
7. Detail pass. Apply the Detail Bar to every hero object: construction layers, attachment, story detail, contact shadow. Done when the object meets its row's minimum (5 prop, 6 tower, 8 creature, 8 landmark), has one asymmetry and one story detail. "Three assemblies" is a blockout; it is not a pass. Do not animate a placeholder.
8. Animation and systems. Locomotion, idle, tower/machine actions, reactions, exits/deaths, goal contact, crowd variation. Done when each hero actor has all five animation layers and each tower has acquire/fire/impact/recovery.
9. Effects. Contact shadows, smoke, splash, spill light, debris. Done when the effect is visible but never the subject.
10. QA. Detail and animation audit, qa/audit.mjs for seams/glows/fades, camera/render scale, exits and emitters, desktop/iPad/phone, file:// standalone, zero page errors, motion and camera proven from numbers and strips. See Verification.

New Subject Intake

A new subject is not a new pile of props. Before modelling, fill this sheet. Copy templates/DESIGN.md into the project and keep it in sync with the code.

PREMISE
  [place] + [a repeated verb/ritual] + [who or what interrupts it] + [payoff].
  One sentence. If it has no verb, it is a shelf model, not a diorama.

CAMERA SIDE
  Which face is +Z? Where is the threshold, the hero tower, the foreground prop?
  Which silhouette must never be occluded from this angle?

CAST SHEET
  role | silhouette feature | locomotion | action | reaction | exit/death | signature
  ...

SYSTEM SHEET
  loop length | three or four systems | crew | three or four visitor roles |
  goal/disruption (optional) | economy/score (optional) | what changes

BEAT SHEET (absolute seconds)
  0.0  establish / portal / doors
  ...  first signal, first system output, first consequence
  ...  disruption reaches the goal (or the last customer arrives)
  ...  contact / handoff / finale, residue, loop seam

DETAIL BUDGET
  systems n x parts | vehicles n | creatures/people n | props n | landmark n |
  exits/deaths n | ambient loops n | triangle / draw-call ceiling

Rules that keep a new subject from becoming a blockout:

• Invent the conflict. If the user says "a diorama of a lighthouse", decide what the lighthouse does, who arrives, what goes wrong, and what the keeper does about it. A subject plus a verb is a diorama.
• Give every machine an operator. If a tower, loom or pump needs a crew, model the crew and decide what happens when they die: the machine slows, stops, or runs unmanned with a visible consequence. A gun that fires itself while its crew lies dead is a ghost. If the machine is autonomous, say so in the sheet.
• Choose five signature moments before modelling. Establish, first system output, first consequence, goal/handoff contact, final residue. A social diorama may use establish, ritual, disruption, handoff, residue. Every object earns its place by serving one of those five.
• Stage for the locked camera. Put the threshold and the hero action on the +Z face; put tall landmarks at the back but offset in screen x so they do not stack. Put one foreground prop at the near corner for depth and one mid-ground prop to lead the eye.
• Blockout in grey first. Boxes, cylinders and the camera, no palette, no post. Shoot 1:1. If the five moments do not read in grey, detail will not save them. Redesign the staging, not the textures.
• Name every hero object. totem, hayCart, gatehouse, troll, not prop12. Unnamed objects become clutter because nobody owns their silhouette.
• One boss goal, one tower verb. The boss must visibly act on a place (door, bridge, pump, nest); the tower must visibly act on a target (pierce, blast, freeze, chain). Repeat the verbs with variation, not new nouns.
• Write the QA timestamps now. Pick the five frames you will inspect before you build them. If you cannot name a timestamp for a beat, it is not staged.

Reference Density

The Hollow Toll shipped at this density. Use it to calibrate a new subject; a smaller subject should have fewer objects at the same detail per object, not fewer details per object.

Measure	Value
Slab	21 x 14 x 0.42 m, 64-colour palette
Towers	4 + 2 gate cannons
Species	5 (goblin, orc, slime + split, bat/imp, troll)
Units	42, one boss
Combat events	527
Tower shots	183
Scene meshes	~3,100
Triangles	~164,000
Scene draw calls	~1,700 at 1440 x 900
Textures	5
Loop / sim	46.0 s at 40 Hz pre-sim
Standalone	~783 kB with three.js inlined

A 12 x 9 m scene with two towers and three species should land around 1,000 to 1,600 meshes and 60 to 100k triangles. Raw count is not the goal; the detail per hero object and the number of readable beats are.

Worked Example: The Hollow Toll

This is the reference build the numbers above come from. Read it as a calibration of what "finished" looks like, not as a scene to copy.

• Set. A 21 x 14 m slab, purple portal at the back-left, winding road, goblin camp, moat and drawbridge, gatehouse at the near-right. Four towers and two gate swivels; keep gate faces +Z.
• Cast. 14 goblins, 4 orcs, 7 slimes plus 10 split slimelets, 6 imps and one Toll-Troll: 42 units, 5 death grammars, one boss goal.
• System. 46 s loop at 40 Hz, 527 events, 183 shots. Ballista single target, bombard splash, frost lance channel, tesla chain, gate swivels on the last stretch. The troll reaches the gate at 38.6 s and hits it eight times.
• Detail. The gatehouse has a plinth, two towers, crenellations, a gate arch, door leaves with cracks, two swivel cannons, banners and torches. The skull warning tree has a trunk, fork, trophy board, horned skull, rope collar, bone chimes, rags, tally marks and roots. The hay cart has a bed, slats, two spoked wheels with iron tyres, corner straps, three tied bales, loose straw, a pitchfork, a sack, a rag and two shafts.
• Animation. The frost spire pulses, flares at the crystal, holds a scrolling band lance, ramps heat, and shuts off on the target's death. The troll stops outside the threshold, turns three-quarter, swings an iron-banded maul, and drives the door flash, shake and cracks from the same gate-hit timestamp. Every species has its own collapse and debris.

Fixes that became rules in this file:

Report	Root cause	Rule
"rocks flying out of the entrance"	camp smoke billboards above the portal	clear the threshold of smoke, props and fireflies
troll inside the gatehouse	stop at length - 1.05, body through wall	stop at body depth + weapon reach; keep the door visible
club looked like a rock	end-on pose, haft hidden, no bands	yaw 0.35 rad, build haft + bands + studs, sync contact
beam had a black segment	black backing plate in the additive beam texture	clear the canvas; transparent gaps, never black
deaths were spheres/rocks	generic burst	species collapse + debris + dropped gear + residue
skull tree looked like a monster	a second totem overlapped the tree	one landmark per silhouette; mount the skull on a board
cart looked like a blob	pale spheres in an open box	five-part prop: bed, slats, wheels, load, tools, story
standalone broke over file://	String.replace expanded $& in the bundle	function replacer; test the standalone

A new subject should copy the density and audit discipline, not these nouns. A lighthouse, market or launch pad needs the same number of readable systems, the same five animation layers and the same proof frames.

Worked Example: Night Market

The social-scene calibration: no combat, no boss, no deaths. A food truck, a queue, a courier, one scooter and a cat. It proves the same discipline applies to a life scene.

• Set. 21 x 14 x 0.42 slab; truck at (0.15, -3.35) with the hatch facing +Z; counter at z 1.10; parked scooter at (5.55, -0.72) facing +Z; bench, rail, lamps, bins, service block behind. Camera azimuth 45, elevation 33, fov 20.5, fill 0.93.
• Cast. Cook, cashier, customers A/B/C, courier, late customer D, cat. The cat is an actor with its own idle, walk, sit and tail loop, not set dressing.
• Systems. Grill flare, order rail, bag pass, scooter dispatch. Four readable systems, no towers.
• Loop. 46 s at 40 Hz. Queue forms 0–16 s; four paper bags + one insulated bag; courier loads 21.2–22.5, mounts 22.7–23.5, departs 23.5–27.3; D arrives 26.0–33.4, last bag 34.0, exits 34.8; quiet seam 40–46.
• Scale. The user asked for 30% smaller. The fix was subjectScale: 0.70 after the fit (distance = fit / 0.70), not scaling the slab, cast or canvas; geometry scaling breaks the world clip and shadow maps, and shrinking the canvas breaks the 1:1 crops. Backing buffer 2x CSS for the faces, CSS downscale.
• Proof. Nine 1280x800 frames plus two close strips: courier mount, D walk. The strip camera was a fixed side view, not the hero camera.

Fixes that became rules in this file:

Report	Root cause	Rule
"the building bottom/right is cut"	slab edge/backdrop closed too tight	close side walls and undersides; camera fit includes the slab corners
"bike lights look unnatural"	large additive disc	emissive lens + small halo; cone only at night
"doesn't put the box on the bike"	prop teleported from hands to crate	carry in world space from wrists; lower over the rim; release with a beat
"doesn't sit on the bike naturally"	car seat/root constants reused	measure scooter seat; board for the left boot; abduction swing; bars to hands
"the human/cat doesn't look human"	sphere head, cap at theta 1.85	skull+jaw head, hair cap 1.22, ears/brow/lids, tapered limbs
"carry the bags more human-like"	prop at root, hands nearby	two-hand hold at the prop's top, object origin at its bottom
"no text outside the diorama"	DOM overlay on the paper	empty-paper rule; copy on modelled signs only
"30% smaller"	scaling the scene	move the camera; keep world clipping and shadow scale
"leg swings over the handlebar"	hip X flexion for a side mount	abduct with hip Z; knee tucked; root arc 0.1–0.2 m
"single human slides near the shop"	standing gesture blended during walk	gate gestures on !state.moving; serve after arrival

A new subject should copy the timing discipline and contact logs, not the food truck. A pool, a station or a bakery needs the same queue/service, carry/load and close-up proof.

Palette And The Post Pass

templates/post.js renders the scene to an offscreen target, then a full-screen shader turns it into pixel art. Order matters; each stage assumes the last.

1. Coverage gather. ~12 taps in a small disc read alpha, so the silhouette can be softened and stippled without blurring the interior. The target is transparent outside the slab.
2. Composite onto paper. mix(vec3(1.0), c, smoothstep(0.26, 0.72, cov)).
3. Gamma. c = pow(c, 1/2.2). The target is linear; skip this and the frame is dark and muddy, which reads as a lighting bug.
4. Grade. Saturation 1.07 and contrast 1.028 before quantising, or the snap flattens everything to mid tones.
5. Ink. Neighbour luma differences, edge = max(abs(d)), brought to display scale with pow(edge, 0.4545), then ink = smoothstep(0.13,0.34,edge) * smoothstep(0.20,0.55,cov) * (1 - smoothstep(0.86,0.985,cov)) mixed 0.62 toward vec3(0.085,0.082,0.076).
6. Dither, gated. d = bayer8(gl_FragCoord.xy) - 0.5, gate = smoothstep(0.004,0.055,edge), c += (d*(0.0012 + 0.019*gate) + sparkle*0.0012) * uDither. Keep uDither as a uniform: it is the fastest way to prove whether a speckle is the dither.
7. Palette snap. Nearest entry with channel weighting (1.0, 1.12, 0.93) so greens do not beat skin. Keep the runner-up and break near-ties toward the lighter entry, or a surface halfway between two entries flips entry per pixel on the dither noise and stipples a whole pavement.
8. Rim dither. Where coverage is 0.78 to 0.995, threshold against Bayer so the cut-out edge is stippled, not anti-aliased.

The palette length is a shader constant: uniform vec3 uPalette[N] in the fragment source and the JS array must be the same length. A mismatch loses the last colours or reads out of bounds, and the symptom is a colour that "does not exist in the palette" appearing on screen.

Tuning Table

Symptom	Cause	Fix
Water looks like TV static	dither ungated	add the edge gate
Frame dark and muddy	missing gamma	pow(c, 1/2.2) before grade
Everything mid-grey	no grade before snap	saturate 1.07, contrast 1.028
Scribble outlines	ink threshold too low	0.13 / 0.34
Missing outline on figures	rim suppression too wide	narrow to 0.86 / 0.985
White speckle on flat deck	material grain aliasing	cut grain, not resolution
Bands with hard edges	palette hole	add 4 to 6 intermediate entries
Speckle only where a tone sits between entries	palette tie	break near-ties toward lighter
Speckle at zero dither	sub-pixel geometry	widen detail to ~1.5 px or delete it
Beam goes flat or vanishes on paper	additive white over white	saturated palette core + dark halo; fade before the edge
Glow disappears after the snap	sub-pixel or pure-white FX	widen to 2 px+, use a palette entry, add a contour
Beam ends in a hard vertical cut	world clip plane on a read-through FX	taper intensity to zero before the slab edge
Flame reads as a grey smudge	normal-alpha smoke over a bright source	lighten/remove smoke in the flame corridor, draw flame last

Isolate noise in this order and stop at the first that removes it: dither uniform to 0 → widen or delete sub-pixel geometry → disable shadowMap. Judge on a 1:1 crop; a downscaled preview softens all three into "texture".

Resolution

Default: setSize renders one target pixel per CSS pixel, capped by maxDim (1600), and CSS image-rendering: pixelated handles the upscale. The chunky look comes from the palette snap and the ink, not from a low buffer.

When the diorama is deliberately small on the page (subjectScale under ~0.8), raise the buffer a little instead of enlarging the subject: new PixelPost(renderer, 2000, 1.25) renders 1.25 target pixels per CSS pixel; at a 1312 × 760 CSS canvas that is a 1640 × 950 buffer, CSS still 1312 × 760. The post pass quantises at the finer grid and the browser downsamples; the page size, camera solve, slab and clip do not move. 1.2–1.5× is the useful range; 2× on a full arena is usually a frame-rate tax, not more art. Log post.size and canvas.getBoundingClientRect() and check a 1:1 crop for shimmer.

For faces and close-up contact beats, use renderScale: 2 and image-rendering: auto (not pixelated), with maxDim high enough (2400) to avoid the cap. The post pass still quantises at 2×; the CSS downscale is a clean box filter, not a change to the art. Keep the CSS size as the layout size so the camera solve and the 1:1 QA crops stay comparable. Re-run the portraits after any resolution change: raising the buffer exposes hats, stripes and noses that hid at the old grid.

Camera And Framing

CAMERA = { fov: 20.5, azimuth: 45°, elevation: 33°, target: (0,-0.15,0),
           fillX: 0.84, fillY: 0.86,
           subjectScale: 1.0 } // 0.70 = 30% smaller, more paper

The distance is solved, not typed: build a direction vector from the angles, project each fit point (slab corners at deck and underside, plus the tallest building corners) into camera axes, and bisect the distance until every point's |x|/(depth*tan*aspect) and |y|/(depth*tan) fit inside fillX and fillY. 48 iterations is plenty. fillX/fillY are the fit margin, not the page-size control; tune them together, because raising one alone crops the other axis on a portrait phone.

Subject scale is a second, post-fit move. Solve the fit first, then pull the camera back:

const fit = solveDistance(aspect, points);
const scale = CAMERA.subjectScale ?? 1;
const distance = fit / Math.max(0.1, scale);
camera.userData.fitDistance = fit;
camera.userData.subjectScale = scale;
camera.userData.distance = distance;

subjectScale: 0.70 renders the diorama at 70% width/height — 30% smaller linearly and about 49% less screen area — so the paper margin grows. 1.0 is the fitted size. Keep the slab, cast, world clip, shadow camera, CSS canvas and frame at full size; raise the backing buffer only with renderScale (next section), never by scaling geometry. Shrinking the geometry also shrinks contact shadows and the clip volume; shrinking the frame/canvas changes the 1:1 crop and does not change the model's scale. Move the camera.

A phone is already height-limited, so 0.70 can make the trucks unreadable. Try 0.70, then 0.80–0.90 if needed; the scale is per scene, not a universal 30%.

Verification. Log both distances and assert actualDistance ≈ fitDistance / subjectScale within 2%. Also project the slab and compare its width to the fitted width: the ratio must be the scale, not just the distance. On Dust Kings at 1.73 aspect: fit 67.93, scale 0.70, actual 97.05; projected slab width 872 → 611 px (0.70), with slab, clip and shadows unchanged.

updateCamera(camera, aspect) on every resize and orientation change, with a debounced call after orientationchange. A canvas measured at under 2 px is a layout race: return early rather than dividing by zero.

Scene Furniture

• Slab 21 x 14 x 0.42 with the street on the camera side (+Z) and the building block at the back (-Z) for an exterior. For an interior cutaway, see Cutaways And Glass before placing the street. Deck at y 0 is the street; the pavement is a raised 0.16 slab with a kerb face.
• Pavement joints 2.6 m apart, 0.085 m wide. Anything thinner rasterises to dots that read as noise. groundY(x,z) returns street, pavement or step height so every track and shadow samples the same function.
• Buildings are boxes with a parapet, a sign band, recessed windows and a door pivot. At 33 degrees you look down onto roofs: a 4.6 m wall in front of a 5.2 m deep building hides none of its roof, so model the parapet, plant, skylight or stair head, or keep it lower than it is tall.
• Doors are pivots at the jamb with the leaf extending into the opening. Recess them 0.15 so the opening shows a shadow gap, and light the interior so an open door reads as a room, not a hole.
• Contact shadows are one unlit radial-gradient plane per figure, opacity 0.55 to 0.95, scaled to the footprint, 0.018 above the ground it belongs to.

Night, Practicals And Headlights

Night is a new light ratio and a new palette, not the day rig dimmed. The sun table is a daylight default; a 2am scene needs its own numbers and its own test.

Key	Night default	Why
moon / key	0x93a7c4 at 0.45 to 0.65	cool, low, soft shadows
hemisphere	sky 0x1b2740, ground 0x090b12, 0.16	blue ambient, never black
fill	0x6d7f9e at 0.10 to 0.16	keeps the shadow side readable
practical	0xffb066 at 1.0 to 1.4	warm bulb/lamp, 2700 K
pool	unlit radial plane, opacity 0.28 to 0.45	light on the ground, cheap
headlight	0xfff0c8, lens + cone + floor ellipse	source, throw and landing

• A practical is an object, not a glow. Bulb sphere, shade/guard, bracket, emissive lens, small halo, and a pool on the surface below. A floating halo with no fixture reads as a firefly.
• Use one real point light at the hero practical, not one per bulb. The rest are emissive + pool decals. Ten point lights flatten the darks and cost more than they return.
• Keep three dark values. Deep shadow, mid shadow and lit edge must be different palette entries; if the night is one black silhouette, lift the hemisphere or add a cool rim. 0x000000 is forbidden, as in daylight.
• Headlights are a moving pool, not a global spotlight. Two lenses, two tapered cones, one elongated floor ellipse that travels with the vehicle. Do not let the cone light the whole facade: it will read as dawn.
• Windows are dark glass with a warm interior. A blue-grey pane, two reflection streaks, and a visible warm room behind it. A fully transparent plane tints the whole interior and kills the cutaway.
• Grade for night after the snap: lift black to about 0x0b1020, keep warm highlights from clipping. Test a 1:1 crop: three dark values, a visible source, a readable pool, no white blob.

A night scene passes when the unlit areas still have shape and the light sources are in the frame. "It is dark" is not a pass.

Cutaways And Glass

The +Z street convention is for an exterior. If the hero action is inside a shop and the street is between the camera and the hero, the bus/traffic will occlude the beat. Choose one:

• Exterior scene: street on +Z, facade behind it, action on the pavement.
• Interior cutaway: omit the camera-side wall entirely (or keep a 0.25 m header and sill), put the street behind the room at -Z behind glazing, and keep the camera-side floor open. The room is the stage; the street is the cyclorama.
• Foreground traffic: allowed only if it crosses before or after the hero's contact beat; check the occlusion frame, not just the still.

For glazing, build the frame, mullions, sill and a few reflection streaks. Do not lay one transparent plane across the opening: it tints the interior, hides the practical lights and turns the cutaway into a fish tank. If the bus must read through the glass, give it lit windows and a dark body against the warm interior; do not brighten the whole room to compensate.

Detail Recipes

Detail is a hierarchy, not a texture. Build in this order and stop adding when the silhouette is explained.

The Five-Part Prop

Every readable prop answers five questions with geometry:

1. What touches the ground? Feet, skids, wheels, a stone base, roots. Add a contact shadow at 0.018 above the deck.
2. What holds it up? Posts, frame, legs, axle, brace. This is the construction layer and it must be visible from the camera.
3. What is its working surface? Planks, slats, a lid, a blade, a trough, a table. Divide it into pieces; a single slab reads as a box.
4. What attaches the parts? Rope, iron straps, nails, hinges, lashings, rivets. Two or three are enough; a row of identical studs is noise.
5. What is the story? Contents, a tool, a repair, a trophy, a rag, wear on the edge that is used. One or two, placed where the camera sees them.

A hay cart from the reference build: bed, six side slats, two spoked wheels with iron tyres, four corner straps, three tied bales, loose straw, pitchfork, sack, red rag, two draft shafts. That is ten assemblies for a prop the user sees for two seconds. A crate with a pale sphere inside is none of them.

Tower Anatomy

A defence tower is a small building, a machine and a crew in one silhouette.

Layer	What it adds	Failure if missing
1 foundation	plinth, steps, rubble, contact	tower floats or looks pasted on
2 shaft	taper, buttresses, bands, ladder	reads as a cylinder
3 platform	deck, rail, hatch, brackets	machine has nowhere to stand
4 machine	weapon, pivot, rail, recoil travel	attack has no origin
5 crew	gunner, cranks, spotter, ammo	tower feels automated/empty
6 livery	banner, number, pennant, paint	tower has no owner
7 wear	scorch, chips, rope, spent cases	tower looks unplaced

The animation pivot belongs to layer 4. The muzzle or launch point belongs to the weapon, never the tower centre. Recoil travel is 0.1 to 0.25 m for a ballista or cannon, 0.02 to 0.06 for a beam crystal. A tower with no recoil, no crew and no ammo is a monument.

A hollow object must show its opening. A cannon with a solid brass cap is a baton, not a gun; the same failure turns a pipe into a rod, a chimney into a post, a lamp into a mushroom and a tunnel into a painted arch. Build the opening as geometry, not a dark decal:

• replace the end cap with one or two open-ended collars (no front face);
• add a recessed dark bore tube, open at the mouth, with its inner wall visible (DoubleSide on a cloned material, never on the shared palette material);
• close the back with a dark disc so the barrel interior is not see-through;
• add an iron inner lip ring and a brass outer lip ring so the edge catches the light at 1:1;
• put the muzzle/effect origin at the lip, not inside the bore.

At 1:1 the opening needs a dark centre at least 5 to 6 px across and a lit lip. If the centre is brass, the hole failed.

A rotating assembly owns only its moving parts. The yaw/turret group may contain the carriage, barrel, recoil slide and muzzle. Fixed stores — powder keg, shot pile, rammer, tools, ready rack, crew — belong to a static group on the tower root, never the yaw group. If they are children of the yaw group they sweep around the tower when it tracks a target, which reads as the whole gun deck rotating.

Do not simply reparent the props at deck height: the barrel and carriage sweep through that volume at some yaw. Put them outside both the yaw sweep and the barrel's vertical arc. If the deck has no clear sector, bolt a ready locker to the outer wall below the deck: shelf, two iron brackets, powder chest with corner straps, shot tray, and a rammer hung on two hooks. It reads as part of the tower and never collides.

Test two ways at minimum and maximum yaw: each fixed child's world position delta must be 0, and each fixed mesh's world bounding box must not intersect any mesh under the yaw group. Both checks pass, or the station is still in the arc.

Worked example, Bombard Bastion: 17 fixed parts — shelf, two iron brackets, powder chest, lid, two corner straps, rope handle, shot tray, tray lip, three iron shot, rammer shaft, iron cap and two wall hooks. It sits at y 1.1 to 1.6 on the outer shaft, below the deck and outside the barrel arc. At both yaw extremes all 17 world positions are identical and the station has zero bounding-box hits against the yaw group.

Creature Anatomy

A creature needs a silhouette feature before it needs a face.

1. Core mass. One dominant volume: hunched torso, round slime, long bat.
2. Silhouette feature. Horns, ears, hump, wings, tail, crest, antlers. This is what the user recognises at 30 px.
3. Face. Two eyes, brow, jaw or beak. Eye sockets must be dark and set in, not painted on the surface.
4. Limbs. Joint groups with fillers; hands and feet larger than anatomy suggests, or they disappear at this scale.
5. Gear. One weapon, one strap, one trophy. Not a full armour set.
6. Colour break. One hue for skin, one for cloth, one metal accent.
7. Asymmetry. A chipped horn, a single pauldron, a dragging club. Perfect symmetry reads as a toy soldier.

The boss gets 40 to 60 parts and one signature weapon. Build the weapon as a separate group with a haft, head, bands, studs or spikes, and a hand attachment. A stone head with no haft reads as a rock floating at the door.

Small Quadrupeds (Cats, Dogs)

A cat is not a small human on all fours. Build a horizontal spine and four contact legs; the silhouette is the back line, ears and tail.

• Body: chest sphere r 0.085 at y 0.24, belly capsule 0.24 long, hip sphere r 0.080. Shoulder height 0.26, nose-to-tail base 0.46. A cat at human scale is about 0.25 m at the shoulder; measure, do not scale a person by 0.2.
• Head: skull r 0.075, muzzle 0.045 forward, jaw, nose, two triangular ears (cones or three-vertex prisms) at the top corners. Eyes face forward with a dark socket and a vertical pupil; at 30 px the ears and pupils carry the read.
• Legs: four chains (upper 0.10, lower 0.11, paw 0.05). Front legs are straighter; rear legs have a hock that bends backward. Paws land flat, toes forward. Do not use the human knee sign for a hock.
• Tail: four to six segments with a slow S-curve, root at the sacrum. It counter-sways against the walk and curls when sitting; a rigid stick tail is the fastest way to lose the animal.
• Walk: lateral-sequence four-beat, phase offsets roughly LF 0, RH 0.25, RF 0.5, LH 0.75. The spine dips and rises twice per cycle; the head stays level. Drive phase from distance travelled, like the bipeds.
• Sit: haunches down, rear hocks folded, front legs straight, chest up, tail curled around the paws. A sitting cat is a triangle, not a crouched person.
• Jump: crouch (hips down, spine compressed), extend (all four legs push), airborne (legs tucked, tail up), land (front paws first, then rear). Two seconds of anticipation and recovery, not a linear hop.
• Fur: one base colour, a lighter chest/muzzle, darker ears/tail tip and two or three stripe bands. Do not model individual hairs; the palette snap eats them. Contact shadow is one stretched ellipse under the body, not four paw blobs.

Shoot the cat at 1:1 in profile, three-quarter and sitting. If it reads as a rabbit, the ears are too long; if it reads as a dog, the muzzle is too broad and the back line too straight. No gear, no trophy, no human jacket.

Environment Anatomy

• Three scale cues. One small (grass, bones, cobbles), one human (cart, barrel, spear), one tall (tower, tree, gate). Without all three the slab has no scale.
• Three story props. A camp, a repair, a warning, a toll, a shrine. Place them off the main path but inside the camera cone.
• Two ambient loops. Fire, flag, smoke, fireflies, grass, water, hanging bones. Phase them differently; synchronized loops read as a screensaver.
• A path with a memory. Ruts, footprints, dropped goods, a worn threshold. A clean path is a diagram.
• A boundary treatment. Trees, rocks, posts or a wall that explains why the slab ends. Do not let props clutter the threshold.

Detail Audit At 1:1

Before the animation pass, inspect each hero object at 1:1 and answer:

• Can I name its three construction layers without guessing?
• Does it cast a contact shadow and touch the ground?
• Is there one asymmetry or story detail I can point to?
• Does it overlap another object of the same silhouette?
• Is any detail under 1.5 px, and therefore speckle?
• Does every hollow object — cannon, pipe, chimney, lamp, tunnel — show a real opening, or does it end in a cap?
• Does it read in grey, without colour?

If any answer is no, fix the object before animating it. Animation multiplies detail; it does not create it.

The Cast

A 1.69 m figure built from primitives, with an anatomical group per joint so limbs overlap when they bend. Faces +Z.

Constant	Value	Notes
hipY	0.86	pelvis group height above the root
hipX	0.10	half stance width
thigh	0.42	hip to knee
shin	0.40	knee to ankle
shoulderY	0.415	above the pelvis
shoulderX	0.182	half shoulder width
upperArm	0.30	shoulder to elbow
foreArm	0.27	elbow to wrist
headY	0.584	neck to head group

The base swimwear rig uses two spheres (cranium 0.115, jaw 0.089) plus a nose box. For a clothed cast, replace that with the skull/jaw/cheek head below. Torso and pelvis are lathes (0.135→0.198 and 0.105→0.180), flattened 0.72 in Z so the body is an oval, not a tube.

Construction rules:

1. Build joint groups at the pivot, hang geometry down (-Y) from them, so a rotation is an anatomical rotation.
2. Every joint gets a sphere filler just inside the limb radius. Without it a 90 degree bend shows a wedge-shaped hole.
3. Limbs are capsules; torso and pelvis are lathes for a tapered silhouette.
4. Clothing is layered over the body as its own lathe slightly larger than the pelvis or torso, plus a band cylinder at the waist or chest.
5. Never parent a part to a group that has not been created yet in the function body: straps added before the torso exists throw on load.

Pose API: setPose(person, pose), easePose(p, pose, 1-exp(-22*dt)), blendPose(a, b) (component-wise add). Angles are [x,y,z] radians per joint: torso, head, shoulderL/R, elbowL/R, wristL/R, hipL/R, kneeL/R, ankleL/R, optional pelvis.

Sign conventions, get these right once:

• Facing +Z. Positive hip X swings the thigh backward; negative forward.
• Positive knee X bends the heel backward. Negative hyperextends and reads as a broken leg. This single sign error is the most common "the walk is broken".
• Positive shoulder X swings the arm backward, negative forward.
• Negative elbow X folds the forearm toward the face.
• Positive shoulder Z abducts an arm away from the body; mirror the sign.

Detail that pays, in order: the skull/jaw head in Clothed Cast (hair cap theta 1.22, eyes at ±0.037, 0.110, 0.101); cap as a crown cylinder, band and brim; brow and lid creases; a narrow nose bridge; a three-layer mouth; ears as flattened spheres; hands as a palm plus a finger block and thumb; feet with a toe box. Fingers, nostrils and micro-seams do not survive 30 px.

Balaclava: one sphere shell over cranium and jaw (r 0.134, scale 1.0/1.10/0.99) plus a neck gaiter cylinder running into the collar. A cover cut at the equator leaves a band of skin under the hem that reads as a bare head, and eye openings tucked under the shell disappear: put pale lids a few millimetres proud of it. A darker skin material is skin.clone() with color.multiplyScalar(0.86).

Clothed Cast: Heads, Layers, Hands

The skeleton is shared; the person is made by the head, the garment silhouette and the hand contact. For a clothed cast, start from templates/peopleModel-street.js; templates/peopleModel.js remains the swimwear/aquatic variant.

Head. A skull plus a jaw, not two stacked balls.

• Cranium: sphere r 0.100 at y 0.118, scale [0.98, 1.16, 0.98]. Jaw: r 0.079 at y 0.054, scale [0.78, 0.80, 0.86]; chin r 0.029 at y 0.029, z 0.079.
• Ears: flattened spheres at x ±0.098, y 0.101, with a darker inner bowl. They are what makes the head read in profile.
• Eyes: a shade socket, a dark iris r 0.0145 scaled flat, a pale catchlight. Brow above, lid crease below, cheek plane under that. At 30 px the socket and brow carry the expression; the iris just anchors the look.
• Nose: a narrow bridge box plus a tip sphere, 0.022 wide. A single box reads as a beak from three-quarter.
• Mouth: upper lip in shade, dark seam, lower lip in skin. Three thin layers at most; a wide box reads as a letterbox.
• Hair: a sphere cap with thetaLength 1.22, positioned at y 0.132 and stopping at the hairline. A 1.85 cap swallows the forehead and reads as a helmet. Add a back mass, sideburns, and for a bun a high sphere at y 0.204. Under a hat show a nape tuft; under a full helmet show none.
• Hats are their own silhouette: beanie (dome + rolled torus + pom), cap (crown
  • brim + band), bandana (cap + knot + tail), helmet (shell + visor + chin strap + reflective bands). Never draw hair through a helmet or a cap.

Clothing is geometry, not paint.

• Base body: torso lathe 0.135→0.198, pelvis lathe 0.105→0.180, flattened 0.72 in Z.
• Garment: a second lathe 4 to 12% larger (topK 1.0 tee, 1.05 jacket, 1.12 puffer), plus a hem/waistband cylinder. The garment must have a thickness step at the cuff, collar and hem or it reads as body paint.
• Sleeves: short sleeve ends above the elbow with a cuff ring; long sleeve is a second lathe down the forearm with a ribbed cuff. Do not texture a bare arm and call it a sleeve.
• Trousers: tapered lathes over thigh and shin with a cuff at the ankle and a break over the shoe. Loose trousers get a wider profile and a deeper cuff, not a scaled leg.
• Outerwear: jacket shell + zip/lapel/hem; puffer gets 3 horizontal quilt bands; hoodie gets a kangaroo pocket and drawstrings; apron is a front panel with a bib, waist ties and a towel, never a full cylinder around the body.
• Backpack sits behind the torso with two shoulder straps that cross the front; a bag floating at the spine reads as a growth.
• High-vis, reflective bands and lanyards are thin boxes proud of the cloth, following the body curve at 2 to 4 mm.

Hands are the contact proof. Palm box 0.070 x 0.078 x 0.054, a finger block with two grooves and a thumb capsule. A glove is the same geometry in glove material, with a cuff. When a hand holds something, the palm and finger block must touch it; a wrist near a handle is not a hold.

If the head or the clothing is wrong, fix it before the walk. A good gait cannot rescue a sphere head or a painted jacket.

Animation

Every motion is a pure function of t or of a distance along a track.

const swing = Math.sin(phase), cs = Math.cos(phase);
const kneeL = 0.05 + 0.46*Math.max(0,-cs) + 0.22*Math.max(0, swing);
const kneeR = 0.05 + 0.46*Math.max(0, cs) + 0.22*Math.max(0,-swing);
pose = {
  torso: [lean, swing*0.05, 0],
  shoulderL: [-swing*arm, 0, -0.09], shoulderR: [swing*arm, 0, 0.09],
  elbowL: [-0.16 - Math.max(0, swing)*0.28, 0, 0],
  elbowR: [-0.16 - Math.max(0,-swing)*0.28, 0, 0],
  hipL: [swing*amp, 0, 0.03], hipR: [-swing*amp, 0, -0.03],
  kneeL: [kneeL,0,0], kneeR: [kneeR,0,0],
  ankleL: [-kneeL*0.32,0,0], ankleR: [-kneeR*0.32,0,0],
};

• Hips above ±0.35 read as a march; 0.30 to 0.34 is a walk, 0.5+ is a run with lean 0.26 and elbows near -0.75.
• Match travel to stride or feet skate: footTravel = 2*legLength*sin(amp), speed = footTravel * phaseRate / PI. A 0.86 leg at 0.34 rad and 5.2 rad/s is about 0.9 m/s. Drive phase from distance travelled, not from time, and the walk always matches the path.
• A track is a Catmull-Rom sampled to an arc-length table with groundY heights smoothed by three 1-2-1 passes, so steps read as ramps. at(d) returns position and heading.
• Sit: hip X around -1.35 to -1.50, knee +0.5 to +1.3 so the shin drops vertically, torso back 0.05 to 0.1. Seat height is a measured constant.
• Climb: hands start above the head, opposite hand and foot move together, hips stay close to the ladder (0.12 to 0.2 m) and swing 0.06 to 0.10. Rung spacing 0.30 m, climb 1.0 to 1.2 m/s, phase driven by height, not time. Feet land on rungs, not between them; the shadow belongs on the ladder/deck, not the slab.
• One-shot actions (jump, dive, kick) are phase tables with eased poses, never a blend between two loops. Hoist shared easing factors above the branch: a const declared in one branch and read in another throws every frame and freezes the figure. Pose targets are full poses, not deltas.
• Airborne arcs are solved backwards from the impact: for a fixed flight T, vy = (landY - launchY + 4.9*T*T)/T. A guessed vy either lands late or stops in mid-air.
• The rig root is at the feet, so a rigid-body spin sweeps the model around its toes: rotate about a pivot C with p' = p + C - R*C, C about 0.55 up.

Carrying, Loading And Mounting

These are the beats closest to the camera and the ones users report first. A prop that teleports, a hand that misses it, or a leg that swings through the handlebars destroys the whole miniature.

Carry. Keep the prop in world space and solve its transform from the hands every frame; do not parent a big prop to a wrist group (it inherits the wrist roll and swims).

const hl = new THREE.Vector3(), hr = new THREE.Vector3();
J.wristL.getWorldPosition(hl); J.wristR.getWorldPosition(hr);
const mid = hl.clone().add(hr).multiplyScalar(0.5);
bag.position.set(mid.x, Math.min(hl.y, hr.y) - 0.42, mid.z);

• Build the prop with its origin at the bottom centre. Then a hold offset is a single subtraction, and the same object seats on the ground/crate floor without a second pivot.
• Two hands for anything heavier than a paper bag. The palms must be within 0.08 m of the prop surface at every sampled frame; log the wrist positions and the prop bounds.
• Match the carry pose to the weight: heavy box at the belly, shoulders -1.2 to -1.4, elbows -1.2 to -1.4, torso lean 0.2; a light bag hangs from one wrist with the elbow nearly straight.
• Reduce arm swing while carrying; the legs do the walking. A full arm swing with a box in the hands reads as a puppet.
• Handoff: at contact, set the prop to the receiver's hold for one frame, then blend ownership over 0.2 to 0.3 s. A hard parent switch pops even when the world positions match.

Loading into a crate or hatch.

1. Lift the prop above the rim in front of the chest, with both hands on it.
2. Tuck the prop's x/z over the opening while the hands stay on it.
3. Lower it until its base reaches the floor; keep the hands on it for a beat.
4. Release, step back, and only then close the lid, clip the bungee or turn away.

Never translate the prop from hands to slot in one frame, and never let it descend outside the crate wall. A bungee or lid that intersects the prop on the way in must animate open and closed; hiding it for the whole beat reads as a missing part.

Mounting a scooter, bike or horse.

Author the mount in the vehicle's local frame, from a measured seat/board, not by eye.

• Place the left boot on an outboard running board or peg. If the vehicle has none, add one; standing on the body or the seat reads as a doll being posed.
• Swing the right leg out to the side with hip Z abduction (about +0.9 to +1.25 rad), knee flexed 1.2 to 1.4. Hip X flexion swings the leg forward, through the handlebars; that is the common error.
• Raise the root in a small arc (0.10 to 0.20 m) so the boot clears the saddle, then drop onto the seat. Do not hop a body-height above it.
• Seat root = the pelvis mesh's contact point, not the rig origin. Sit with the pelvis on the cushion, both boots on the boards, knees 0.9 to 1.1 rad, toes forward; hands reach the grips with soft elbows. Move the bars to the hands before hyperextending the arms.
• A rider pose is not the standing pose rotated: torso upright 0.15 to 0.25, hips flexed -0.9 to -1.1, hips abducted ±0.25 to ±0.35, knees 1.0 to 1.1, ankles near -0.05.
• Keep the vehicle and rider on the same mover after departure, with the rider root attached to the seat anchor; a bob applied to one and not the other separates them.

Proof. A nine-frame side strip at 0.15 to 0.25 s spacing: approach, lift, over-rim, lower, release, step, leg-swing, seat contact, ride. Shoot it at 1:1 and log wrists, ankles, prop base and seat. A still cannot prove a mount.

System And Combat Animation

The character section above covers body mechanics. This section covers the systems that carry a diorama: towers, projectiles, reactions, deaths, bosses, crowds and secondary motion. Every one is a pure function of t, driven by a pre-simulated event list.

The Five Layers In Code

Layer	Driver	Typical period	Use
ambient	sin(t*f + phase)	1.5 to 5 s	breath, flame, flag, scan
locomotion	distance along a path	stride length	walk, fly, hop, slither
action	absolute event time	0.3 to 1.2 s	fire, swing, slam, dive
reaction	event time + direction	0.15 to 0.5 s	flinch, flash, knockback
death	absolute death time	0.6 to 1.4 s	collapse, debris, residue

If an action and a reaction share a clock, derive both from the same event timestamp. Two independent cycles will drift apart even if they match on the frame you happened to inspect.

Deterministic Timeline

const DT = 1 / 40;
const LOOP = 46.0;

const pulse = (t, t0, tau) => (t < t0 ? 0 : Math.exp(-(t - t0) / tau));
const win = (t, t0, dur) => clamp((t - t0) / dur, 0, 1);
const easeOutCubic = (u) => 1 - Math.pow(1 - u, 3);
const spring = (t, t0, freq = 9, damp = 6) => {
  const a = t - t0;
  return a < 0 ? 0 : Math.exp(-damp * a) * Math.cos(freq * a);
};

Run the battle at DT from 0 to LOOP once at load. Store:

events.push({ t, kind: 'shot', tower, target, from, to, flight, damage });
events.push({ t, kind: 'impact', x, y, z, species, dir });
events.push({ t, kind: 'death', id, type, x, y, z, t });
events.push({ t, kind: 'gate', x, y, z, hit: n });

The render loop reads the events whose time has passed. It never re-simulates and never carries state between frames. ?t=12.4 freezes the whole system, including effects, so every QA shot is reproducible.

Tower Attack Grammar

A tower attack needs five visible stages. Cut one and the tower reads as a spawner, not a weapon.

Stage	What the player sees	Time
acquire	head/turret turns; crew leans; crystal brightens	0.15 to 0.4 s
wind-up	rail pulls back, arm cocks, coil charges, barrel vents	0.1 to 0.35 s
release	muzzle flash, string snap, beam origin flare, arc jump	1 to 2 frames
travel	bolt, ball, beam, chain, projectile with trail	0.05 to 0.6 s
impact	flash on target, dust/goo/ice/feathers, ring	0.1 to 0.25 s
recovery	recoil returns, crew resets, smoke clears	0.2 to 0.5 s

Tower archetypes:

• Ballista / arrow. Slow traverse, rail recoil 0.15 m, string snap, bolt with a short trail, thunk and a small dust puff. Reload is a winch crank.
• Cannon / bombard. Breech recoil 0.2 m, muzzle flash and a smoke ring, arcing iron ball, impact dust and a ground ring. Never rock debris.
• Beam / lance. Crystal pulses, origin flare, a sustained channel with a scrolling texture, a target flash, a heat ramp. The beam dies on the frame its target dies and respects line of sight. Never a static white cylinder.
• Tesla / chain. Coil hum, charge glow, a jagged arc that hops to two or three targets, capacitor fade. The arc must visibly leave the coil.
• Support / aura. A ground ring with a clear radius, a pulse that travels outward, a colour shift on affected units, and a caster animation that shows the source. No invisible buff. Audit it as a field, not a shot: origin, area, ramp, affected-target change, decay.
• Rotating emitter / lighthouse. A continuous sweep is not a turret. Keep the base sweep theta(t), add a short dwell window when a target crosses the beam, and ease in/out of the dwell so the housing never snaps. Fire inside the dwell; return to the sweep with the same phase it would have had. If the beam can point into the goal pocket, mask that sector physically (back-screen, shroud) rather than breaking line of sight with a special case.

If the tower has a crew, the crew reacts: brace, pull, cover ears, crank. A crew that stands in the same pose through a cannon shot is a mannequin.

Machine Grammar (non-combat)

A loom, press, crane, oven, pump or lighthouse lens is not a tower, but it needs the same causality. Replace "attack" with work:

Stage	What the player sees	Time
engage	clutch drops, belt tightens, valve opens, lamp housing turns	0.15 to 0.4 s
work	beam sweep, flywheel spin, ram stroke, dough stretch, water flow	0.3 to 3 s
output	light pool, pressed sheet, lifted crate, baked loaf, water rise	0.1 to 0.5 s
settle	flywheel coasts, valve closes, belt slackens, lamp returns	0.2 to 1 s

Audit: input (what feeds it), motion (what turns/strokes), output (what changes in the world), residue (waste, heat, crumbs, steam). A machine with a beautiful motion and no output is a kinetic sculpture; give it a product and show the product.

Goal Response Vocabulary

A boss or disaster must act on a goal, not just a door. Pick the response from the goal's material:

Goal	Contact response	Failure
door / gate	flash, shake, crack, dust from the lintel	leaf hangs, ward closes
valve / pipe	spray, gauge drop, pipe shudder, hiss	pressure falls, lamp starves
rope / bridge	slack, sag, strands snap, deck drops	span falls, route closes
wall / dam	chip, crack, water seep, block falls	breach, flood
tree / mast	bark split, creak, tilt, leaves fall	trunk breaks, canopy drops

Put the contact point on the silhouette edge of the goal, not buried in its body, and keep it clear of the boss's shoulder/weapon. If the goal is tall, put the contact at chest height and turn the boss 0.3 to 0.4 rad so the weapon shaft crosses the frame. The response and the contact must share the same timestamp.

Projectile Grammar

1. Spawn at the muzzle, rail tip, hand or crystal, not the tower centre.
2. Give it a fixed flight time or a solved arc; do not integrate physics in the render loop.
3. Add one trail or one tumble. A bare sphere is a debug object.
4. On impact, switch to a species-specific effect: dust and ring for iron, splinters for wood, goo for slime, feathers for flyers, ice shards for frost.
5. Remove it on the impact frame. No projectile survives its target.

A projectile that is visible after the target is dead is a bug, not a flourish.

Creature Animation Grammar

Archetype	Locomotion	Action	Reaction	Death
small scrapper	scamper, 2-beat	quick stab	flinch + skid	cloth, knife, stain
brute	heavy walk, shoulder roll	overhead cleaver	stagger, shoulder dip	iron plates, sword, dust
slime	squash-hop	lunge	wobble, split	goo splat, two lets
flyer	flap, bank, hover	dive	spiral, feather burst	feathers, spiral fall
boss	weight shift, slow stride	telegraph + slam	recoil, knee dip	collapse, gear, weapon, soul

Every creature gets a hit flash on the body material for 0.08 to 0.12 s and a directional flinch opposite the impact. Do not reset the whole pose on a hit; blend a flinch over the current pose and recover.

Death is a sequence, not a switch:

1. Impact frame: freeze or compress the body, flash, drop the weapon.
2. Collapse: 0.25 to 0.5 s; knees buckle, torso folds, flyer spirals.
3. Species debris: 5 to 8 pieces of cloth, iron, goo, feathers, bone.
4. Residue: a stain, scorch, splat or dropped gear that stays for 1 to 3 s.
5. Soul: a brief additive flicker or wisp, 0.2 to 0.4 s, then gone.

A death that is a sphere burst, a grey puff or a rock shower fails the bar even if the particle count is high.

Boss Choreography

A boss exists to act on a place, not to have more hit points.

• Stop it outside the threshold by body depth + weapon reach. At the gate, that was 2.0 m short of the path end, which left the troll on the drawbridge with the door visible behind the club.
• Turn it three-quarter to the goal (about 0.35 rad off the door axis) so the weapon shaft reads across the frame instead of end-on. An end-on club head is a grey rock at the door.
• Build the weapon as a separate group: haft, head, two iron bands, six studs, six spikes, and a visible hand attachment. A stone head with no haft is a floating rock.
• Telegraph 0.4 to 0.7 s, contact 0.1 s, recovery 0.3 to 0.5 s. The contact pose is driven by the same gate-hit pulse as the door flash and crack.
• Put the door response on the same timestamp: flash, shake, crack, dust. If the club hits at 41.075, the door cracks at 41.075, not 41.2.
• Lose the tower's line of sight to the gate pocket while the boss is there. A beam arriving at the same pixels as the club steals the beat.
• Prove it with two shots: contact frame and contact +0.2 s. The first shows contact and flash; the second shows recoil. If the club is hidden at contact and only appears on recoil, the pose is late.

Crowd Variation

• Phase offset per actor: phase = hash(i) * TAU, never one global sin(t).
• Vary speed by 4 to 8 percent, scale by 2 to 4 percent, and idle by phase.
• Stagger spawns and attack windows by at least 0.15 s. A shared window makes a group move like a chorus line.
• Give each actor a lane or offset on the path; two actors at the same waypoint stack into one silhouette.
• At a shared door or gate, one actor reaches the threshold; the rest hold back at 0.9 + i * 0.8 along their own path.

Secondary Motion

Flags, banners, cloth, chains, hanging bones, smoke and fire are the cheapest way to make a static scene feel alive. Rules:

• Drive with sin(t * f + phase) and a phase offset per object.
• Add a lag of 0.1 to 0.2 s behind the parent motion; cloth that moves exactly with the body looks rigid.
• Keep amplitude small: 0.03 to 0.12 rad for cloth, 0.02 to 0.06 for chains.
• Cap the count. Six flags at different phases read as wind; twenty read as noise.
• Never let a secondary object enter the threshold pocket or cover a face.

Animation QA

For every hero actor, capture:

• a 6-frame strip of locomotion at 0.1 s spacing;
• the action contact frame and contact +0.2 s;
• the death at impact, mid-collapse and residue;
• the boss contact at the door plus recoil;
• the beam at full channel and the frame after the target dies;
• a pivot parentage strip: freeze at minimum and maximum yaw and log the world positions of every fixed deck prop. They must not move; only the turret and its carriage should. Also check world bounding-box overlap between the fixed station and every mesh under the yaw group: zero hits.

The strip passes when feet plant, knees bend backward, no joint opens a wedge, no part floats, and the silhouette changes between frames. A still cannot prove an animation; a strip can.

Service And Queue

A market, hatch, ticket window or bakery is a queue machine: people arrive, advance one slot, order, pay, receive and leave. Build the queue before the props; it is the scene's clock.

Slots. Lay four to six positions along the counter, 0.65 to 0.80 m apart, perpendicular to the hatch. Everyone in the queue shares one lane and one heading; a diagonal queue reads as a crowd, not a line.

const SLOTS = [q0, q1, q2, q3]; // q0 is at the hatch, q3 is the tail
const toSlot = (p, slot) => ({ x: slot.x, z: slot.z });

• A customer's mover is a sequence of seg(t0, t1, track) legs: enter → tail → advance one slot per serve → counter → exit. Keep each leg on its own track; re-pathing every serve makes feet slide.
• Advance the whole queue on the serve timestamp, with a 0.06 to 0.12 s stagger by slot. The person at the hatch does not advance; they receive and turn away.
• When a customer leaves, the next walks into the vacated slot; do not teleport the queue forward while the camera is on it.

Customer state machine.

State	Visible action	Gate
arrive	walk with distance-driven gait	until slot reached
order	point at menu/board, head turns	only when speed = 0
pay	hand to counter / phone	after order, only when still
wait	idle, weight shift, phone	until bag lands
receive	both hands or one hand out	at bag contact
exit	turn, walk out, carry bag	after receive + 0.3 s

The gate is the whole fix. Never blend a standing gesture (PAY, POINT_MENU, RECEIVE) into a walking pose. If the gesture has straight legs and the walk has bent knees, the mix straightens the legs while the root keeps translating: the figure glides. Compute state.moving from the mover and write:

if (state.moving) pose = walkPose(phase, { amp, arm, carry });
else if (t < orderEnd) pose = mixPose(idle, POINT_MENU, bell(t, order));
else pose = idlePose(t, phase);

• Serve after the counter arrival, by at least 0.25 s. A bag that lands before the customer reaches the hatch is the second-most-reported queue bug.
• One action at a time: order, then pay, then receive. Overlapping windows make the arms fight.
• A late customer may arrive after the queue empties, but only once; reusing the same slot for a second invisible customer reads as a spawn.

Machine slots. A laundromat, workshop or gym uses the same clock with machines in the slots: washer drum → dryer drum → fold table. Advance the batch on the end-of-cycle timestamp, not on a fixed beat, and land the next action 0.25 s after the lid/door closes. A drum that starts tumbling before the door shuts is the machine version of serving before arrival.

Staff side. The cook works the grill; the cashier takes payment and hands the bag across the hatch. Their gestures are independent loops, but the bag's release comes from the cashier's hand position, not a fixed world point. Keep a stack of paper bags at the hatch and decrement it per serve; the last bag is the goal object.

Proof. Freeze the approach every 0.25 s for two strides and log root speed, moving, hip/shoulder angles and slot. The strip passes when the feet alternate, the root advances smoothly, no standing gesture appears while moving is true, and the serve timestamp is after the arrival timestamp.

Vehicles

A vehicle is the prop the user inspects the moment a door opens, so build it to be opened. Model facing +Z.

Part	Size and place	Note
floor pan	1.62 x 0.10 x 4.02 at y 0.35	dark; its top is the cabin floor
rockers	0.12 x 0.16 x 3.92 at x ±0.87	stay with the body
front fender	0.10 x 0.56 x 1.05 at z 1.62	body side ahead of the front door
rear quarter	0.10 x 0.56 x 0.72 at z -1.84	body side behind the rear door
belt moulding	0.10 x 0.08, one per fixed panel	never one rail across the apertures
bulkheads	1.84 x 0.56 x 0.16 at z ±2.12	close the tub
roof	1.48 x 0.08 x 1.94 at y 1.44	drip rails at x ±0.76
pillars	A raked -0.64, B upright, C raked +0.60, 0.075 thick
windscreen	1.44 x 0.62 x 0.05, rotation.x -0.64	glass between the A pillars
side glass	none	windows down: open holes between the pillars

Cabin: dash 1.46 x 0.15 x 0.30 at y 1.00 z 0.80; wheel torus r 0.125 at (-0.40, 1.10, 0.68) rotated -0.42; front cushions 0.46 x 0.10 x 0.50 at y 0.57 z 0.30 with backs at z 0.04; rear bench 1.20 wide at z -0.50 with its back at z -0.74.

The windscreen is not a plane at the front of the cabin: rotated -0.64 it sweeps back to about z 0.59 at its base. A front seat at z 0.72 therefore sits inside the glass volume, and every occupant's head prints on the windscreen from every angle. Keep the cushion's front edge at least 0.25 behind the glass base and move the dash, wheel and column back with it.

Doors. Hinge at the shut line, leaf extends backward in -Z: front 1.15 to -0.15, rear -0.15 to -1.45, leaf 1.30 long and 0.55 high. Pivot at (side*0.86, 0.62, hingeZ), children are outer skin, inner card, sill strip, handle, and any livery; rotation.y = -side * open swings it out. Swing 1.28 rad for a saloon, up to 1.52 for a cruiser. Split every full-length body moulding at the shut lines: a moulding left on the shell reads as the top of the door left behind when it opens.

Boot. Pivot at (0, 0.90, -1.46), lid extends -Z, rotation.x = +0.95 lifts the rear edge. Well floor y 0.44 against a lid underside at 0.89, so cargo must fit 0.45: bags r 0.165 at y 0.63 (tops 0.80) clear it. Close the boot off from the cabin with a parcel shelf (1.74 x 0.05 x 0.66 at y 0.86, z -1.10) and a bulkhead behind the rear seat back (1.74 x 0.46 x 0.06 at y 0.63, z -0.82); without them the boot is open to the cabin through the rear windows and the load reads as sitting on the closed lid.

Cargo carries visible = false until it lands and userData.noMerge = true. A throw needs an object that travels: keep one world-space bag per thrower and arc it hand → slot with p.y += sin(f*PI)*0.6, switching the slot's bag on when the flight lands, not at release.

Scooters, Cargo Bikes And Mounts

A scooter is not a car with two wheels. Build it around the contact points: two tyres on the ground, a floor pan for the boots, a seat the pelvis can sit on, bars the hands can reach, and a cargo crate whose opening is visible from the camera.

Reference local frame, facing +Z, for a delivery scooter at 1.0 scale:

Part	Place	Note
wheels	r 0.26 at z ±0.62	tyre + hub + fender; both touch y 0
floor pan	0.60 x 0.04 x 0.30 at y 0.30	top is the boot surface
running boards	0.12 wide at x ±0.235	outboard, full length; the left boot lands here
body / shield	0.46 wide, up to y 0.72	front leg shield, not a box
seat	top 0.83 at z -0.18	measure the cushion top, not the body
bars	y 1.06, grips x ±0.33, z 0.52	raise bars to the rider's hands
cargo crate	0.52 x 0.44 x 0.46, base y 0.86, z -0.56	open top, interior floor ~0.91
bungees	two cords across the opening	clip open during loading

• Seat anchor. seat = local(0, 0.83, -0.18); set the root so the pelvis mesh contacts the cushion, then prove it in a seated portrait. On the Night Market scooter that is root y 0.09 against a 0.83 seat; do not copy a seatY - hipY formula from a chair, because the pelvis mesh hangs below the hip joint. A copied root puts the rider on the front edge or floating.
• Boots. Add outboard running boards at y 0.30 if the floor pan is narrower than the rider's stance. Ankles at 0.30, knees 1.0 to 1.1, toes forward; both soles flat. Perching one boot on the body is the "doll on a toy" read.
• Hands. Grips at the wrist height; a rider with hands 0.15 m above the bars is not holding them. Move the bar/riser up or soften the elbow; do not hyperextend the shoulder.
• Cargo. A crate with an open top needs an interior floor and side walls; a bag lowered to baseY + 0.01 sits inside. Keep bungees as a separate group so they can unclip during loading and close over the lid afterwards.
• Lights. One emissive lens plus a small halo sprite; a headlight cone only at night. A large additive disc reads as a floating balloon; a brake light is a second, smaller lens, not a copy of the headlight.
• Clipping. The whole vehicle + rider + cargo move as one mover after departure; clip the group at the slab edge, and hide rider shadow at the same time the vehicle shadow takes over.

Mounting is authored with the sequence in Carrying, Loading And Mounting: left boot on the board, right leg abducted over the saddle, small root arc, pelvis on the seat, hands to the grips. Prove it with the nine-frame side strip.

Buses, Vans And Long Vehicles

A bus is a moving room. Its job is a window band, a door, a route sign and a headlight sweep; the chassis is the least visible part.

Part	Size / place	Note
body	9 to 12 m long, 2.5 wide, 3.0 high	one box with a chamfered roof
window band	y 1.35 to 2.45, full length	dark glass + warm interior, not a transparent plane
door	1.1 wide, front or centre	step well, grab rail, lit interior
wheels	r 0.50, wheelbase 5.5	two axles; arches cut into the skirt
route sign	front above the windscreen	emissive text/colour blocks, readable at 1:1
livery	one band + one number	never a full advertising wrap at this scale
headlights	two lenses at y 0.65	plus cones and a floor ellipse
interior	4 to 6 lit windows + driver silhouette	a dark box with one warm strip reads as a bus

• Speed and weight. 5 to 8 m/s, no bounce; one brake dip at the stop. A bus that bobs like a car reads as a toy. The body leans 0.01 to 0.02 rad on the brake, no more.
• Headlight sweep. Two cones and one long floor pool travel with the bus. Do not light the facade with the cone; a 12 m vehicle with a global spotlight turns night into noon.
• Occlusion. A bus between the camera and an interior hero covers the beat. Put its lane behind glazing at -Z, or time it before/after the contact. Check the occlusion frame at the hero timestamp.
• Doors. If the door opens, model the step well, a grab rail and an interior light; a black rectangle reads as a hole. For a passing bus, keep the door shut.
• Clip. The whole bus, lights, interior and driver move as one group; hide its contact shadow at the slab edge, same frame as the vehicle.

A bus that reads as a white box with black windows is not finished: the window band, route sign, wheel arches and one warm interior strip are the minimum.

Seats, Exits And Transfers

Seat root = cushion top minus hipY, which is -0.38 in car space on this rig: the hips settle into the cushion and a masked head clears the roof with 6 to 8 cm. At -0.18 a hooded head lands about a centimetre under the roof panel and any bob prints a dark pixel on the white roof. Measure against the head mesh, not the head joint, and lower the seat rather than raising the roof, which is pinned to the pillars.

The stand spot is 2.00 m out from the car's centreline and 0.30 behind the hinge for a front seat, 0.55 for a rear:

const exit = toWorld(car, side * 2.00, seatZ - 0.30);

An open leaf hangs in the plane of its hinge, so an exit level with the seat puts shoulders and head through the door skin. 0.30 still sits inside the aperture and leaves room for a torso plus a swinging arm. 2.00 out is about 1.07 of daylight from the flank, and that is not padding: at 45/33 a figure 0.7 off the flank sits wholly inside the car's silhouette with his feet on the rocker line and reads as welded to the body.

The climb is authored in the car's own frame, so it works at any parking angle. It ships: templates/transfer.js is the whole move (transfer, climbAt, CLIMB, stepPose, standSpot), and templates/poses.js carries the four climb poses plus the walk and run cycles it blends between. Copy them, do not retype them. k runs 0 at the open door to 1 at the seat, dy is the root height above the seated root, and the pose is a real sequence: stand, reach, crouch in, sit on the edge, swing the legs in, settle.

const CLIMB = [
  { u: 0.00, k: 0.00, dy: 0.380, pose: STAND },
  { u: 0.16, k: 0.03, dy: 0.330, pose: REACH },      // hand to the roof edge
  { u: 0.36, k: 0.16, dy: 0.120, pose: CROUCH_IN },  // knees deep, hips dropping
  { u: 0.56, k: 0.38, dy: 0.010, pose: SIT_EDGE },   // perched, feet still down
  { u: 0.76, k: 0.66, dy: 0.000, pose: LEGS_IN },    // knees up, feet over the sill
  { u: 0.90, k: 0.88, dy: 0.000, pose: mix(LEGS_IN, SEATED, 0.55) },
  { u: 1.00, k: 1.00, dy: 0.000, pose: SEATED },
];

The transfer wraps that climb: the first STEP_SHARE (0.26) of the window is one stride from the stand spot to the door, the rest is the climb, and on the way out the stride away comes last. The body only reaches cushion height once the hips are over the sill, so nobody sinks, floats or slides through the bodywork. DOOR_STAND_X 1.34, DOOR_STAND_DZ -0.06, durations 1.05 to 1.20 s each way. Never derive the duration from the next beat's start: under about 0.9 s the whole move reads as a slide or a blur. Move the following beat later instead.

Facing is the trap. The outward yaw points away from the car, so a figure entering with it climbs in backwards: body into the seat, face to the street. On the way in every key before the seated ones faces the car, including the standing key that gets forgotten. Resolve it from geometry, never from the approach path's tangent: a path's opening segment runs along the street, so path.at(0).yaw + PI points down the kerb and lands the figure a right angle off whichever way he arrived.

const faceYaw = car.yaw - side * (PI / 2);       // square to the open door
const face = Math.atan2(seat.x - stand.x, seat.z - stand.z);   // stand -> seat
// turn to the windscreen only once the hips are on the cushion
const turn = smooth(clamp((v - 0.62) / 0.30, 0, 1));
yaw = lerpAngle(faceYaw, car.yaw, turn);

Staging rules that came out of real reports:

• One window per actor, staggered 0.2 s or more. A shared window climbs two men into a seat on the same frame, which reads as choreography, and at 0.1 s they climb through each other.
• Separate a pair in screen space, not in world space. At a locked 45/33 view, moving a figure further out along the camera axis barely changes where it lands on screen: it stays stacked over the car's flank and still reads as one blob, which is why pushing the stand spot from 1.6 m to 2.0 m did not cure a "stuck" report. What separates them is offset along the car's axis, because that is screen x: rear occupant 0.72 behind his hinge against 0.30 for the front leaves 1.2 m of screen distance instead of 0.8, where two figures merge into one silhouette. Project both actors with v.project(camera) and compare pixels before concluding they are spaced.
• Doors are a timeline, not a state. Open the leaf 0.15 s before a transfer, shut it 0.5 s after the last man is clear, reopen just before the entry. A car left open for the eight seconds its crew is away reads as the crew stuck in the doorway, however clean the walk is.
• A run that ends at the car must not hand straight into the transfer. End it 0.4 to 0.6 s early, blend out to STAND over the last 12 percent, hold a beat at the door, then climb.
• Seated figures stay visible. Hiding them when the entry ends sends an empty car down the street, which the user reads as a bug, not a cutaway.

Clear Spots, Shut Doors

• A shared doorway needs one lane per actor plus a hold-back on the approach. Actors on the same waypoints put the second in the first's back and stack at the threshold. Offset the approach per actor, stop each one short of the door by 0.9 + i*0.8 along his own path, stagger the walk-in windows by 0.25 s, and let the lead actor alone reach the threshold: the kick, the first step through. Four men then read as a queue filing in rather than a scrum.
• Diagnose "stuck" with numbers, not frames. Freeze in 0.3 s steps across the beat and print every actor's x/z with the pairs closer than 0.6 m. A pair that holds that close for more than one sample is jammed; a single sample is two men passing. At 12 px a figure a screenshot cannot tell those apart, and nudging spacing by eye fixes the wrong thing: the real cause is usually a route that ends where another actor already stands.
• Give every actor a route out of every beat. Two officers left in a cover crouch at the kerb while everyone else moves is a direction bug, and the report is always "they are stuck" however correctly the two are separated.

Clipping At The Diorama Edge

Vehicles enter and leave the block, and the slab is a window. Four world-space planes on the renderer for the scene pass, cleared before the post quad:

const CLIP = [
  new THREE.Plane(new THREE.Vector3( 1, 0, 0), hx + 0.05),
  new THREE.Plane(new THREE.Vector3(-1, 0, 0), hx + 0.05),
  new THREE.Plane(new THREE.Vector3( 0, 0, 1), hz + 0.05),
  new THREE.Plane(new THREE.Vector3( 0, 0,-1), hz + 0.05),
];
r.clippingPlanes = clipPlanes; r.setRenderTarget(rt); r.render(scene, camera);
r.clippingPlanes = [];         // before the full-screen quad

A car entering nose-first shows its own front surfaces at the cut, so the cut reads clean; one leaving tail-first exposes the cut face, so keep the interior modelled and it reads as a cutaway. Route every vehicle one way, in at one end of the street and out at the other, no reversing and no angled parking: an angled park reads as a collision, and backing in reads as a bug. Two vehicles sharing a lane need a departure gap (pLeaveGap ~1.15 s) or the far one drives through the near one.

Effects

• Water: MeshPhysicalMaterial with vertex colours, not a custom shader, so it receives shadows. Ramp shallow to deep teal, never to navy: a near-black end quantises into a hard band the user reads as a hole.
• Wake: unlit additive foam streak plus 8 to 12 expanding ripple rings spawned behind a moving body every 0.4 s, fading as (1-k)^2.
• Splash: 60ish unlit additive droplets with gravity plus four rings and a foam disc; normal-blended white over teal reads as a grey blob. Seed the burst (trigger(x, z, power, burstSeed)), never Math.random: a frozen frame must reproduce the same burst, and the same frame must reproduce it again after the clock jumps.
• Effects that integrate dt need a reset(). Wake and splash advance by dt, so jumping the clock to freeze a frame does not jump their state, and the frozen splash shows whatever the last played frame left behind. Both templates expose reset(); the harness calls it and re-simulates in fixed steps from zero, which took a two-frame diff from 334 differing pixels to 18.
• Smoke: camera-derived billboards. The camera is locked, so copy its quaternion once and every puff is a plane facing the lens.
• Debris with history: loose notes or paper use a solved arc, a drag term, a spin about a random-but-deterministic axis, then slerp to flat and lie there for the rest of the loop. Deterministic hashing (sin(n*127.1)*43758.5 fractional) keeps every replay identical.

FX And The Edge

The slab is a window, but not every effect is a solid. Split them:

• Cut FX — debris, props, vehicles, bodies. Let the world clip plane cut them; model the interior so the cut reads as a cutaway, and route them so they enter and leave rather than parking across the edge.
• Read-through FX — light beams, glow, wake, spray, horizon haze. Do not let a hard clip plane slice them. End the effect at its target, fade intensity to zero before the slab boundary, or mask it with a soft edge. A lighthouse beam that stops in a straight vertical cut reads as a broken cone.
• Additive over white. Additive white on a white page is invisible. Give a beam a saturated core from the palette plus a darker under-edge or halo, and test it at 1:1 against the page, not against a dark viewport. If the beam must cross the whole frame, let it dim toward the edge; a bright hard-ended beam is worse than a soft falloff.
• Clipped water. A hull cut at the slab edge needs its interior and a foam plane at the cut, or it reads as a hollow shell. A moored boat should sit fully inside the frame for the beat where it unloads.

FX Under The Snap

Every scene effect goes through the palette snap. That is the look, but it punishes sub-pixel tricks:

• Author FX at 2 px or wider at the target buffer. A 1 px additive wisp disappears or becomes a single palette dot; enlarge it or delete it.
• Use a palette-legal saturated colour and a dark contour, not pure white. White clips to the page and the snap has nothing to quantise.
• Do not rely on a smooth gradient to carry an effect. Build it from 2 to 4 palette steps, a scrolling band, or a shape with a hard edge.
• Test with ?dither=0 and at 1:1. If the effect only reads in a downscaled preview, it is not in the render.

Contact Contexts

"Touching the ground" is not one rule:

• Ground prop: contact shadow plane 0.018 above the slab; lowest vertex on the deck, not floating.
• Deck / gallery / table: the shadow belongs on that surface at its Y, not on the slab below. Parent the figure and shadow to the deck, or project onto the deck plane; a gallery figure with a slab shadow reads as a ghost.
• Water: the hull sits below the waterline; use a foam ring at the waterline and a wake, not a contact shadow. A floating boat with a hard shadow on the water reads as a toy on a table.
• Vertical / wall: a ladder, hook or rope needs a contact mark at the rung, grille or rail it bites, plus a small recoil; a hook in mid-air is a prop.

Combat Readability (towers, bosses, deaths)

A diorama is judged on whether the cause and the consequence are both visible at the locked camera. Geometry that is correct in world space can still read as a bug on screen. Run these gates before calling a combat beat finished.

• Clear the threshold. Keep at least 2 m of empty ground in front of a portal mouth, gate, or spawn arch. No crates, barrels, boulders, bones, or hanging vines in that pocket. Remove fireflies over the mouth, and never put rising smoke there: a grey billboard above an arch reads as a rock flying out of the entrance, even when it is soft and transparent.
• Give every tower a legible grammar. Origin flare, a readable travel or channel, and an impact that lands on the target. A beam needs contrast against both the tower body and the page (there is no sky), plus motion along its length; a plain white cylinder over a white tower reads as a waterfall or a static icicle. Use a scrolling band texture, a darker halo, and a target flash. If the line of sight is blocked by the keep, a foreground tower, or a ruin, pick another target instead of drawing through the wall.
• A beam that fires at a dead target is a bug. Store the target id on every beam event and hide the beam on the frame its target dies.
• A boss with a goal must act on the goal. Stop it outside the threshold by at least its body depth plus weapon reach, face the door, and make the weapon visibly contact the door. Position alone is not enough: sync the contact pose to the door-hit timestamp (a decaying pulse from the simulation), so the club/ram/fist is low on the same frame the door flashes, shakes, and cracks. If the weapon is off-screen, through the wall, or on the ground at the hit frame, the beat is not finished.
• Do not let an attack hide the story. A boss at the gate and a tower beam arriving at the same spot fight for the same pixels. Let the tower lose line of sight to the gate pocket, or dim/shorten the beam there; the door beat wins. The player can see the beam elsewhere in the loop.
• Deaths need a species, not an explosion. No generic sphere, boulder, or rock burst on death. Use a body-specific collapse plus two or three type-coloured shards or cloth/armour/goo/feather pieces, a dropped weapon where the species carries one, a ground stain or splat, and a brief soul flicker. Cannon and mortar impacts land in dust and smoke with a ring, never in stone chunks. If a death reads as "grey puff", it is not done.
• A stone weapon is not a floating rock. A club, maul, or ram needs a visible haft connecting it to the hand, iron bands, studs, or spikes, and a colour that separates it from the wall it hits. Check the impact crop: if the head looks detached, add the haft/band contrast, not more debris.
• Prove the beat with time, not a still. Shoot the impact frame and the frame 0.2 s later. The first must show contact and the flash; the second must show recoil or follow-through. If the club is hidden at impact and only appears on the recoil, the pose is late.
• Sync effects by timestamp. Gate hits, door cracks, beam impacts, and death pulses must derive from the same simulated event time. Two independent cycles will drift apart on a long loop even if they match on the frame you happened to inspect.

Attack Audit

Run one row per tower, at the timestamp it fires. A tower that never fires in the loop is scenery, not a defence.

Check	Pass condition
origin	muzzle, rail, crystal or hand is visible and offset from the body
wind-up	at least 0.1 s of visible anticipation
travel	projectile or beam is traceable across at least 4 frames
impact	lands on the target with a species-specific effect
recovery	weapon returns; crew resets; no snap to rest
count	shots > 0 in the sim stats for this tower
no stale	no projectile or beam outlives its target

If a tower fails "origin", move the spawn point; adding more impact particles will not fix it. If it fails "travel", slow the projectile or widen the trail; a 1-frame hit is a hitscan, which is fine only for a beam.

Field Audit

A support, aura or ground field has no projectile and must not be failed for that. Audit it on five field stages instead:

Check	Pass condition
source	emitter, valve, horn mouth or caster hand is visible
area	radius/cone is readable on the deck; no floating ring
ramp	effect grows over at least 0.15 s; not an instant decal
affect	affected units visibly change (speed, colour, stagger, burn)
decay	effect fades/expires on the loop, leaving residue
count	events > 0 for this field in the sim stats

A field that never expires is a lighting change, not an attack.

Death Grammar

Species	Body collapse	Debris	Dropped	Residue
goblin	fold forward, knees first	cloth scraps, 2 bone chips	knife or spear	dark stain
orc	drop to one knee, then side	3 iron plates, 2 tusk chips	cleaver or sword	dust + blood
slime	flatten, then pop	6 goo blobs, 1 core	none	glossy splat
flyer	spiral, wings fold	5 feathers, 1 bone	none	feather on ground
human / crew	knees, then hat/coat fold	3 cloth scraps, 1 tool	hat, keys or hook	oil or blood stain
boss	knee dip, torso fall, weapon drop	6 armour plates, 2 horns	club	scorch + rubble

Every death also gets a 0.2 to 0.4 s additive soul flicker. It is the punctuation that says "this was a creature", not "this was a particle system".

Beam And Impact Artifacts

• A black band along a beam is a texture backing, not a shadow. A canvas filled with black and then painted with white stripes still carries black RGB with alpha 1; under a render target it can survive as a dark segment. Clear the canvas and paint pale stripes with transparent gaps. Never use a black background for an additive beam texture.
• A beam that looks like a waterfall is a white cylinder against a white tower. Add a darker halo, a scrolling band texture, an origin flare and a target flash. The eye needs motion along the length and contrast at both ends.
• A beam through a wall is a line-of-sight bug. Sample the keep/foreground silhouette and drop the target if the segment crosses it; do not shorten the beam after it has already drawn through the wall.
• A beam on a corpse is a stale target. Store targetId on the beam event and hide the beam on the frame that id dies.
• Dark smoke over a bright beam reads as a black bite. Smoke is normal-alpha grey; if it crosses a beam, lighten it, move it out of the beam corridor, or draw the beam after the smoke. Do not assume additive blending saves it.
• A projectile that looks like a floating rock has no trail and no muzzle. Spawn it at the weapon, add a tumble or trail, and remove it on impact.
• A muzzle flash with no recoil reads as a sticker. Move the weapon back 0.1 to 0.25 m and return it over 0.2 to 0.5 s.

Prop And Landmark Failures

• Two landmarks with one silhouette. A skull tree behind a skull totem becomes one antlered monster; a cart beside a crate becomes a pile. Remove or move one. Project both to screen and check the union.
• A trophy that floats. Mount it on a board, plaque or branch with a visible rope, strap or nails. A skull in mid-air is a rock with eye sockets.
• Loose skulls at the base read as white pebbles. At diorama scale, a 0.1 m sphere with two dots is not a skull. Remove it or make it a clear bone pile with a jaw and horns.
• A cart load made of pale spheres reads as a blob. Use tied rectangular bales, straw tufts, a pitchfork and a sack. The load must have a construction logic, not just a colour.
• Rising smoke over a threshold reads as rocks flying out. Remove it from the pocket. Fire can glow without a smoke column.
• A prop at the slab edge with its wheel or shaft over the void breaks the cut-out. Move it in until the lowest contact and the full silhouette are on the deck.

Build And Ship

templates/build.mjs bundles src/main.js to dist/app.js with esbuild (IIFE), writes index.html and a standalone HTML with the bundle inlined, escapes </script in the payload, and passes the replacement as a function, not a string. String.replace expands $&, $', $` and $1 inside a string replacement; a minified bundle routinely contains those sequences, which silently injects the <script src=...> tag into the middle of the app and breaks the standalone file. Always test the standalone over file://, not just the served page. --minify for shipping; expect roughly 780 kB with three.js inside.

Freeze and seek come free if everything is a function of t:

const params = new URLSearchParams(location.search);
const frozen = params.has('t') ? parseFloat(params.get('t')) : null;
const startAt = params.has('from') ? parseFloat(params.get('from')) : 0;
window.__diorama = { THREE, scene, camera, renderer, post, director, cast,
  robbers, cops, mats, TL, CLIP, freeze(t){ frozen = t; draw(t); }, play(){}, view(){} };

?t=12.4 is the whole QA surface: every screenshot and every diagnosis is a frozen frame, so a screenshot never depends on timing luck.

The research gate, at ship time

A build is not finished until these exist. Check them before the summary:

• refs/<subject>/ has at least one contact sheet stepped from real footage.
• refs/SOURCES.md answers the four questions (shape, motion, asset, proof) with the queries actually run. "Nothing found" is a valid answer only with the query written down next to it.
• CREDITS.md has a row per imported asset, and every licence is CC0, CC-BY, public domain, or owned by the user.
• Every hero asset walked the ladder: disk, CC0, CC-BY, then hand-built. If it was hand-built, the row says so.
• The captures for each beat exist, and each one was compared against the reference frame for that beat.

A missing SOURCES.md means the research step was skipped, and the scene is probably wearing the generic version of its genre.

Surface, Motion And Event FX

These are the failures that survive a good first render: a finished-looking set with one raw seam, a clean loop with a vehicle that teleports out, or an effect that is technically present but reads as a grey rectangle. Audit them as a system, on every subject.

• Finish the edge, not just the field. A heightfield, bank, road, water or terrain piece that meets the slab must feather to the slab height over the last 0.5–1.0 m. Never end a terrain in a lip, a vertical wall or a portal-shaped hole. Prove it with a 1:1 crop of each visible slab edge at two nearby times, not a wide shot where the seam is 2 px.
• A mover has not exited until its bounds clear the slab. Keep the whole group — body, lights, shadow, cargo — visible through the complete run-out. Hide only after the world-space box is wholly outside the slab plus a 0.2–0.5 m margin. No early visible = false, no parking at the gate, no portal. If the scene uses a clip plane, the mover may be cut by it, but the cut body must continue moving out; a cut that freezes is the same bug.
• Never fade a solid hero with material opacity. Per-material opacity on a multi-mesh vehicle or figure produces ghosting and sort artefacts: some parts turn transparent before others, and the result is a see-through prop, not a fade. Cut, clip, or hide only when the bounds have cleared. Transparent glass and FX are exempt; whole-object fades are not.
• Effects are events, not weather. Exhaust, steam, dust bursts and impact puffs belong to explicit windows: start, rev, launch, hit, landing, open. If the brief does not ask for idle smoke, do not emit while the source is parked. A continuous plume erases the timing of the event it was meant to sell. One-shot exhaust is roughly 0.7–1.2 s, with a short fade tail under 1 s. Check the event frame and event + 1.5 s: present then absent.
• Anchor an emitter at the physical nozzle. For a vehicle, the source is the exhaust-tip object ((±0.66, 3.74, -0.74) * scale on the truck recipe), not the engine centre, cab roof or a point chosen by eye. Put the tip in userData during construction and use that same object for the smoke. A plume that starts above or behind the stack reads as a floating cloud. If a canopy hides the tip, offset the birth point downstream in the open direction, not the source anchor; the audit's maxOffset allows that.
• A halo is a sprite, not a quad. A flat, untextured, low-opacity additive PlaneGeometry is a light-grey rectangle at the palette snap, especially over a dark board or wall. Use haloPlane/softDiscTexture from detail.js, a real emissive lens, or no halo. This is the single most common "what is that rectangle?" report.
• Event FX must not cover the thing you are pointing at. A smoke cloud that grows over a sign, jumbotron, face or gate has become the subject. Cap size, cap life, and move the source to the open side of the prop; verify at the event frame, not only at 60% of the burst.
• Every correction gets a regression check. For these failures the checks are: edge crop pair, mover bounds log, whole-group fade scan, emitter active/quiet windows, source-to-puff distance, flat-glow scan, and margin scan. templates/qa/audit.mjs runs the mechanical ones; the 1:1 crops remain human evidence.

Verification

• Build first, then shoot, then prove the edit landed. A failed bundle leaves the previous dist/ in place, and a refused or blocked edit leaves the source untouched, so in both cases every screenshot shows the old app and the fix looks like it did not land. Read the build's own output line, grep for a sentinel string from the change, and only then judge the frame.
• Judge orientation from the transform, not the pixels. At diorama scale a back and a front read the same: a 4x-downscaled strip once made a correctly-facing figure look like he was climbing in backwards, and the "spin" it appeared to do was an artefact of re-reading the crop. Print group.rotation.y and compare it with atan2(dx, dz) of the expected facing vector before re-shooting a facing fix.
• Screenshot 1280x800, 1388x950 (iPad landscape) and 390x844 (phone). Zero page errors in all three, and the framing holds at each aspect.
• Two shots 1.5 s apart differ (the loop is alive) and the camera position is identical (the angle is locked).
• A 1:1 crop shows square pixels, a dark contour, no speckle on flat deck.
• Pairwise distance sweep across every multi-actor beat: freeze in 0.3 s steps, log x/z and the pairs under 0.6 m. Held for two samples means jammed.
• Position logs across every one-shot boundary: consecutive samples differ by centimetres, never by a body length.
• Isolated portraits per figure: no gaps, knees bend backward, nothing floats.
• Queue gate strip. Sample a walking customer every 0.15 s across two strides; log root speed, state.moving, hip/shoulder angles and slot. No standing gesture may be non-zero while speed is non-zero; the leg angles must alternate; serve must be at least 0.25 s after arrival.
• Carry contact log. During every carry beat, print both wrist positions, the prop's world bounds and the distance from each palm to the prop. The palms stay within 0.08 m until release; the prop does not move more than 0.05 m in one frame except during the authored handoff blend.
• Mount strip. Nine side frames from load to seat; log wrists, ankles, prop base and seat. No boot passes through the bars/seat/body, both soles reach the boards, and the rider root follows the seat after departure.
• Scale check. The 30%-smaller request is a camera move; assert actualDistance / fitDistance ≈ subjectScale, the projected slab width fell by the same factor, post.size ≈ CSS size × renderScale (capped), the slab/world clip/shadow camera and CSS frame are unchanged, and the standalone still frames on the page.
• Night 1:1. Three distinct dark values, a visible practical with a pool, no clipped white, no pure black. For an interior, the glass must not tint the room; for a passing bus, the occlusion frame at the hero timestamp must still show the hero.
• Quadruped strip. Profile, three-quarter, sit and jump. Ears read as ears, pupils are vertical, rear hocks bend backward, the tail curves; a rabbit or a dog silhouette fails.
• Exit strip. For a social actor: contact, turn, walk out, prop in hand. No debris or stain unless the scene is a death; the residue is the changed place.
• When a prop never appears, print its world position rather than trusting visible. getWorldPosition on a merge-eaten object returns local coordinates because the original was unparented; that is the signature of the merge pass.

Per-entity frame recording

A still cannot prove a jump. A six-frame strip cannot prove that the third character in the scene is animating, because the other two are moving in the same picture. qa/frames.mjs records one dense series per entity, and prints a verdict for each, so a dead actor cannot hide behind a live neighbour.

BASE_URL=http://127.0.0.1:4180/index.html \
ENTITIES='({ hero: d.cast[0].model, guard: d.cast[1].model })' \
FROM=4 TO=9 FPS=12 OUT=qa/frames STATIC=guard \
  node templates/qa/frames.mjs

What it does per entity:

• Isolates it. ISOLATE=scene (default) hides every mesh not on that entity's branch, so the signature is really about this actor; siblings hides the other registry entries only. Restored afterwards.
• Fits one camera to the swept bounds and keeps it for the whole window, so travel stays visible. A camera that follows the actor hides exactly the drift you are looking for.
• Samples at FPS (12 by default) across FROM..TO, and for each frame logs the world bounds centre in NDC, plus a 32x32 luminance signature.
• Scores four ways. empty counts frames where the entity is not on screen, energy is the largest mean luminance delta between consecutive on-screen frames (a flat line means the actor is not animating), step is the largest NDC jump (a teleport), and OFFSCREEN counts frames outside the frustum.
• Writes a contact sheet per entity, qa/frames/<name>/sheet.png, and the numbers to report.json. Exit code 1 when anything is flagged, so CI can gate.

Reading it:

Verdict	Means	What to do
ok	moved, stayed inside, no jump	still read the sheet for pose quality
FROZEN	energy under MIN_ENERGY	the pose blend is not reaching this actor
TELEPORT	an NDC jump over MAX_STEP	a state boundary is snapping, not blending
EMPTY n/N	not rendered for over half the window	wrong window, or it spawns later than you think
NOT-IN-WINDOW	never rendered in the window	the entity name is wrong, or it is invisible
OFFSCREEN	left the frustum	staging, camera fit, or a run that goes too far

Two rules for the numbers. A blank frame beside a full one must never be allowed to supply the energy for a window, so only consecutive on-screen pairs are compared. And an entity that is meant to hold still (a seated figure, a guard at a post) goes in STATIC=, or you will get a FROZEN that means nothing.

Run it for every hero actor, and for each scripted beat that involves them: send-out, attack, hit, death, exit. The sheet is the evidence; the verdict only tells you which sheet to open first.

Detail And Animation Audit

Run this after the build and before shipping. It is deliberately visual; a number cannot prove that a club is touching a door.

1. Grey silhouette. Hide the palette/post (or desaturate) and shoot the hero frame at 1:1. Every tower, creature, landmark and prop must be nameable from its outline. If two objects merge, restage.
2. Hero crops. One 1:1 crop per tower, one per species, one per landmark, one per large prop. Look for: floating parts, untextured primitives, duplicate silhouettes, sub-pixel speckle, missing contact shadows.
3. Threshold crop. The gate/portal/spawn mouth is empty for 2 m. No smoke, crates, rocks, bones or vines. The boss's weapon is visible against the door.
4. Attack strip. For each weapon tower: acquire, release, travel, impact, recovery. The muzzle/rail/crystal must be visible at release. For a support, aura or field: source, area, ramp, affected-target change, decay. A defence with zero events is a bug in the sim or the data, not "atmosphere".
5. Death strip. For each species: impact, mid-collapse, residue. Debris must be species-specific. A grey puff, sphere burst or rock shower fails.
6. Boss contact. Contact frame plus 0.2 s later. Contact must show the weapon on the goal, the goal's response (flash/crack, spray/gauge drop, sag/snap) and the first consequence; +0.2 s must show recoil or follow-through. The haft and bands must be visible at contact.
7. Beam/field on/off. Full channel, then the frame after the target dies or the field expires. No black band, no beam through the keep, no beam on the corpse, no field left glowing after its timer.
8. Crowd strip. 6 frames at 0.1 s across a group. Actors must not share a phase, stack at one waypoint, or walk through each other.
9. Numbers. Print events, shots per tower, deaths per species, maxD per species, loop length and console errors. A species with zero deaths did not finish its route; a tower with zero shots never joined the fight.
10. Rectangle and seam test. Look at every large translucent plane and every slab edge in a 1:1 crop. A hard-edged grey rectangle near a sign is a flat quad halo; a step/lip/black slot at the surface is an unfinished edge. Fix both before the standalone pass.
11. Standalone. Open the built HTML over file:// once. ready: true, no console errors, and a frame that matches the served page.

Keep the proof pack: shots/hero.png, shots/tower-*.png, shots/death-*.png, shots/boss-contact.png, shots/boss-recoil.png, shots/beam-off.png. A future chat can compare its own pack to these crops.

New-Chat Handoff

When a different diorama is requested in a fresh chat, the skill should produce the same level without re-deriving it:

1. Read this file and templates/DESIGN.md.
2. Fill the design sheet before coding: premise, camera side, cast, systems, five beats, detail budget.
3. Block out in grey and shoot the five beats at 1:1.
4. Build the pipeline in the order in this file: palette, camera, light, post, props, cast, detail pass, animation/systems, effects, QA.
5. Apply the detail bar per hero object and the animation bar per actor.
6. Run the detail and animation audit plus qa/audit.mjs, not just "does it load".
7. Ship the standalone and leave DESIGN.md, README.md and the code agreeing.

If the new subject has no combat, replace tower grammar with Machine Grammar (loom, press, crane, oven, pump) and creature grammar with character grammar (customer, worker, animal, vehicle). Audit outputs as fields when there is no projectile. The five layers and the audit still apply: idle, locomotion, action, reaction, residue.

Comment Triage

When the user marks a region, project the object instead of guessing pixels: obj.getWorldPosition(v); v.project(camera); px = (v.x*0.5+0.5)*w. If it is not obvious, raycast that pixel and read the first few hits' materials and heights: the first hit is the surface they see, the second is what is under it. Then fix the marked region and nothing else, and prove it with a zoomed crop at the same timestamp.

Pitfalls

• A building's roof is a large visible surface at 33 degrees. Look down onto it and dress it, or keep buildings lower than they are deep.
• A merge pass eats anything whose visibility is animated. Batching same-material siblings keeps one visible flag, so hidden cargo comes back as a single invisible mesh that never appears, and the survivor's getWorldPosition reports local coordinates. Tag runtime-toggled meshes userData.noMerge = true.
• Canvas size is presentation, resolution is the buffer. Shrinking the display keeps the buffer; moving the buffer changes the art. renderScale 1.2–1.5× on a small subject sharpens it without making it larger; measure fps and inspect a 1:1 crop before keeping it.
• Raising the buffer exposes geometry that hid at the old grid. Re-run the portraits after any resolution change: floating hats, detached stripes and oversized noses show up there first.
• A prop swallows a figure placed inside it. Sit the figure on the near rim with the limbs outside; more detail inside will not read anyway.
• Lying bodies convert joint Z rotations into vertical lifts. Flatten shoulders to about ±0.15 and keep elbows near zero.
• A springboard must move and the rider must follow it: pivot at the root, integrate a spring on rotation.z, and put the feet on pivotY + h*cos(flex) - arm*sin(flex).
• A standing gesture blended into a walk straightens the legs and slides. Gate PAY, ORDER and POINT on !state.moving; a still at one timestamp will not catch it, a 0.15 s strip will.
• A carried prop parented to the root leaves the hands at the first turn. Keep it in world space, solve from the wrists each frame, and log palm-to-prop distance.
• A leg swung with hip X goes through the handlebars. A side mount needs hip Z abduction, knee flex and a small root arc; hip X is for walking and sitting.
• Shrinking the geometry or the canvas frame to satisfy "smaller" shrinks the world clip, contact shadows and slab, or changes the 1:1 crop. Move the camera with subjectScale instead; the frame and backing buffer stay fixed.
• A DOM caption on the white paper is outside the diorama. Model the sign or use the browser title.
• A hat hovering above the skull is a brim at 0.225 instead of 0.192.
• Oversized nose: 0.044 at this camera is a snout, 0.038 is a nose.
• Two figures at 0.8 m read as one silhouette. Judge spacing from numbers.
• A shared window synchronises a group. Stagger every actor's window.
• A door left open beside idle actors reads as stuck in the doorway.
• A pose switch is not a transition. Cutting from a run into a transfer pops the whole body: blend out over the last 10 to 15 percent and hold a beat.
• A cannon with a brass end cap is a baton. Hollow collars, a recessed dark bore, a back disc and a lip ring; the hole must survive the 1:1 crop.
• Fixed deck props parented to a yaw group sweep with the gun. A powder keg, shot pile, rammer or crew member under the turret turns with every aim. Put them on a static wall locker outside the barrel arc, not just on the root at deck height; test world positions and bounding-box overlap at both yaw extremes.

Project Layout

DESIGN.md              filled design sheet: premise, cast, systems, beats, budget
CREDITS.md             every imported model: URL, author, licence (CC0/CC-BY/owned)
refs/                  reference frames: contact sheets stepped from the source clip
refs/SOURCES.md        research log: query -> found -> decision, per question
src/
  config.js            scene constants + clamp/lerp/smooth/pulse/hash
  main.js              renderer, scene, clip planes, resize, rAF, ?t= freeze
  core/
    palette.js         N entries + named C map
    post.js            PixelPost: gamma, grade, ink, dither, snap, rim
    materials.js       every material, palette-validated
    geometry.js        roundedBox, addBox, lathe helpers
    merge.js           mergeSiblingMeshes: one draw per material per group
  scene/
    camera.js  lighting.js  street.js  bank.js  props.js
    car.js             shell, doors, boot, seats, cargo
    peopleModel.js     base rig (swimwear/aquatic)
    peopleModel-street.js  clothed rig: heads, layers, hats, hands
    people.js          the cast: poses, walk/run, tracks, buildCast
    stage.js           the beat sheet + every actor as a function of t
    effects.js         contact shadows, smoke, spill, siren
build.mjs              esbuild bundle, index.html, standalone HTML
qa/
  shoot.mjs            viewports + console errors + named timestamps
  probe-*.mjs          one-off numeric probes (facing, anchors, NaN, spawn pose)
  audit.mjs            scene lint: halos, fades, camera/render scale, exits, FX
  portrait.mjs         isolated figure/framing shots through a debug camera
  strip.mjs            N-frame motion strips (fails on a frozen loop)
  probe.py             colour runs across an edge
  sweep.mjs            pairwise distances + jam/teleport verdict
  tile.py              tile a motion strip
  README.md            audit contract, commands, failure table

Wire order in main.js: renderer → scene → camera → post → clip planes → lights → materials → street/bank/props → cars → cast → effects → merge → stage. Merge once, before the stage is created, so the timeline binds to the surviving meshes.

A defence or arena subject replaces street/bank/car with path/towers/keep:

src/scene/
  path.js          route samples, arc length, at(d), ground height
  towers.js        foundations, machines, crew, recoil pivots
  monsters.js      rig, poses, walk/fly/hop, boss club
  keep.js          gate, walls, door leaves, cracks, goal response
  roster.js        species stats and wave table
  battle.js        deterministic 40 Hz sim, shots, impacts, deaths, gate hits
  props.js         camp, skull tree, cart, torches, trees, portal dressing
  effects.js       beams, projectiles, dust, smoke, shards, rings, souls

The same wire order applies: build the set, then the cast, then effects, then merge once before the battle timeline reads the survivors.

When the beat sheet moves into its own module, delete the superseded director and update the README's beat table in the same pass. An unreferenced six-hundred-line timeline and a table that disagrees with the code are exactly what the next reader trusts.

templates/ carries runnable copies, not excerpts. Foundations: post.js, palette.js, camera.js, lighting.js, geometry.js, build.mjs. Cast and motion: peopleModel.js, peopleModel-street.js, poses.js (the pose library, including the four climb poses and the walk/run cycles), transfer.js (seating, the climb, stand spots, facing), track.js (arc-length paths with lane offsets and smoothed ground height), stage.js (beat table, keysAt, place, the actor loop, a car state machine). Props and systems: detail.js for prop assemblies (including haloPlane/softDiscTexture for soft light cards), combat.js for deterministic timing and death grammar, creature.js for a fight between two rigged actors (stage-local aimYaw, bone-space headAnchor, uprightQuat, the makeHurtModel severity table and sendOut throw-and-return geometry). Effects: water.js, wake.js, splash.js. Sheets: DESIGN.md, CREDITS.md, SOURCES.md (the research log, filled before the first mesh).

stage.js ships as a skeleton with one worked actor chain: a figure leaves a car, walks a route, comes back and climbs in. It is deliberately not a story. The structure it does ship is the part that is tedious and easy to get wrong: beats ordered monotonically in t, one branch per actor per frame, the contact shadow following place(), and the door as a timeline rather than a state. Replace the cast, the routes and the beat table; keep the skeleton.

car.js is still not in the kit. A vehicle is the most subject-specific prop in the scene, and the recipe (dimensions, door pivots, windscreen versus seat, boot well, livery split) is written above at the length it needs. Everything else you need is a file.

qa/ is the harness: shoot.mjs (viewports, named timestamps, console errors, the buffer/camera/draw-call line), audit.mjs (flat-glow, whole-object fade, camera/render-scale, early-hide, teleport, idle/orphan emitter and margin checks against the optional scene contract), portrait.mjs (isolated figures through the debug camera), strip.mjs plus tile.py (motion strips, which fail on a frozen loop), probe.py (colour runs across an edge, the tool for "why is there a band here"), and sweep.mjs (pairwise distances across a beat, with a two-sample jam verdict and a teleport limit). They need playwright-core and a page that exposes window.__diorama with freeze(t); verify/water/ is a worked example that exercises the three water modules and shows what the acceptance output looks like.

Skill Maintenance

The skill is part of the deliverable. After every shipped diorama, do a ten-minute postmortem and write down what the user actually reported, not what you intended.

1. Add at most three rules per routine project. A skill that grows by fifty small rules becomes unreadable and the next reader skips it; a deliberate major overhaul is a versioned release, not a stealth append.
2. Every rule needs evidence and a test. "Clear the threshold" came from a screenshot of smoke above a portal; the test is a 1:1 crop of the pocket. "The club must touch the door" came from a still at 41.075; the test is the contact frame plus 0.2 s.
3. Promote repeated fixes. If the same bug appears twice, it is a missing rule, not a one-off.
4. Retire stale rules. If a template or pipeline change makes a rule obsolete, remove it in the same edit.
5. Bump the version. Patch for wording, minor for a new rule/section, major for a new contract or a reorganisation. Keep SKILL.md.bak-v<old> beside it.
6. Update the templates and the project layout in the same pass. A rule that points at a file that does not exist is worse than no rule.
7. Test the skill on a new subject. After a major edit, give a fresh model only this file and ask it to fill DESIGN.md for a different diorama. Fix every contradiction it finds; that is cheaper than discovering them after a build.

A useful postmortem entry has this shape:

BUG:    the club read as a rock at the gate
CAUSE:  end-on pose; haft hidden; no bands
RULE:   turn the boss 0.35 rad to the goal; build haft + bands + studs
TEST:   contact crop at the gate-hit timestamp; haft visible, head on door

Two entries from the truck-diorama correction pass:

BUG:    a light-grey rectangle floated beside the jumbotron
CAUSE:  a flat, untextured, additive PlaneGeometry used as a glow
RULE:   halos need a radial-alpha map, an emissive lens, or deletion
TEST:   qa/audit.mjs FLAT_GLOW plus a 1:1 crop of the board at the hero time

BUG:    both trucks vanished at the gate before the run-out finished
CAUSE:  visible=false keyed to a beat, not to world bounds clearing the slab
RULE:   hide only after the box is outside slab + 0.2–0.5 m; never fade solids
TEST:   qa/audit.mjs EARLY_HIDE over the full loop; exit strip at 0.2 s spacing

BUG:    the yellow truck smoked while parked, from a cloud above the cab
CAUSE:  continuous idle haze plus a guessed emitter point inside the body
RULE:   one start/rev event window, puffs born at the real stack tip; offset the
        birth point downstream if a canopy hides it, never the source anchor
TEST:   qa/audit.mjs IDLE_EMITTER / ORPHAN_EMITTER; event frame present,
        event + 1.5 s absent

Field Notes: Two-Creature Combat

From a Pikachu vs Charizard battle diorama built against Sword/Shield and anime footage. The rig, the effects and the send-out all broke in the same three ways, and the fixes generalise to any fight between two rigged actors.

Aiming is a local-space problem

Both rigs look down their own +Z, and both sit under a stage root that is rotated (here 90°). Reading a world-space bearing to the opponent and writing it to a local rotation.y aims the two past each other, toward the lens. Compute the yaw inside the stage's own frame:

const camLocal = cameraDirection.clone().applyAxisAngle(UP, -STAGE_ROT);
const aimYaw = (a, b, cheat) => {
  const dx = b.x - a.x, dz = b.z - a.z;
  return Math.atan2(dx, dz) + camLocal.x * cheat;   // local, not world
};

Then prove it numerically, every half second, through the whole loop: forward vector versus vector-to-opponent should sit at 0.97+, and it may only dip during a deliberate spin. Eyeballing this at 300 px hides a 20° miss.

Effects belong in bone space, not world space

Flames leaving a mouth must be anchored to the head joint, or they slide off the jaw whenever the head turns. Convert the parent's forward and up into the target bone's local space once at build time and keep the emitted point there:

const localFwd = bone.worldToLocal(pivotPoint.clone().add(forward)).normalize();

Same idea for the aim of a projectile: take the muzzle from the bone matrix, not from a hardcoded offset.

Flat effects need an upright basis

quaternion.setFromUnitVectors(+Z, viewDir) picks an arbitrary roll, which is why a kanji-shaped blast can arrive upside down or rotated 40°. Build the basis from the lens explicitly:

const right = new THREE.Vector3().crossVectors(worldUp, viewDir).normalize();
const up = new THREE.Vector3().crossVectors(viewDir, right).normalize();
mesh.quaternion.setFromRotationMatrix(new THREE.Matrix4().makeBasis(right, up, viewDir));

Explosion vocabulary

A hit burst is a hot core with ten short sparks radiating out of it, plus a ring on the ground. That is the whole recipe; it reads at any size.

• No cone petals, no triangle fans, no straight bars, no scaffolding around the blast. Every one of those reads as geometry, not energy.
• Layered silhouettes beat layered spheres: a body colour, a hot mid, a core, each scaled individually (m.scale.set(k,1,1) per layer) — sharing one geometry between layers makes the layers invisible.
• A continuous stream is one mesh with overlapping segments. Separate quads with per-segment jitter make a ladder with seams.
• Nested cones hide their own core: nudge the inner layers toward the lens and lift them so the hot tip clears the outer silhouette.

Pin the effect to where the hit landed

An eruption anchored to actor.position every frame crawls across the slab while the actor slides out of it, which is exactly the "something feels off, it moves a bit" report. Latch the anchor once, at the moment of impact, and animate from that fixed point. Same for the projectile's target: aim at the latched point, not at the live chest position.

Send-out and recall are different verbs

• Send-out: the trainer throws. The ball leaves the hand on an arc, spins, lands on the mark, the lid opens with a white burst — flash, smoke puff, sparks, a ground ring — and the creature springs out at full size, covered by the flash. The ball then snaps shut and returns to the trainer's hand.
• Do not replace that with a slow orb the creature materialises inside; that is the legendary-encounter variant, and it reads as a bubble.
• The red beam belongs to a recall or a knockout, never a send-out. If the ball glows red before release, it reads as a second, wrong beam — keep the release white.
• If the trainer holds a second ball while the thrown one is in the air, hide the held prop for the duration or the throw doubles.

templates/creature.js ships these five as runnable functions: aimYaw, headAnchor, uprightQuat, makeHurtModel, sendOut.

Hit reactions scale with the attack

One hit model, four severities: a light flinch (0.9 s, a tip back), a knocked-back stagger (1.7 s, air time), a spin-out (1.3 s), and a full collapse (3.5 s, falls, lies down, gets up). Rotate about the axis of the blow ([dz, 0, -dx]), pivot at mid-body so the actor rocks rather than hinging at the feet, and add a small vertical arc so the feet leave the ground.

Changelog

• 3.8.0 — qa/frames.mjs: a per-entity frame recorder. Samples one dense series per entity across a window, isolates it (branch, siblings or full scene), fits one camera to its swept bounds so travel stays visible, and scores every entity: energy (flat means frozen), step (NDC jump means teleport), empty frames, OFFSCREEN, with STATIC= for actors meant to hold still. Each entity gets a contact sheet plus a row in report.json, and the script exits non-zero on any flag. New Per-entity frame recording section in Verification. New Long builds and context section: compaction is lossy, so state lives in DESIGN.md, SOURCES.md, CREDITS.md, report.json and the beat table, and a post-compact agent re-runs the harness instead of trusting its summary.
• 3.7.0 — Research-first release, from the Pikachu vs Charizard battle diorama. New Research Before You Model section: step the source footage into contact sheets and write the motion grammar down before modelling, prefer game footage over fan cuts, and check free commercial-use libraries (Poly Pizza, Sketchfab CC0/CC-BY, Quaternius, Kenney, user-supplied AI meshes) before hand-modelling a creature; CREDITS.md + licence gate + fitModel pipeline + forward-axis probing; shots-as-acceptance-test. New Field Notes: Two-Creature Combat section: stage-local aiming with a numeric facing sweep, bone-space effect anchors, upright billboard basis, explosion vocabulary (no cones/bars/ scaffolding, per-layer scaling, one continuous stream), latching effect anchors to the impact point, send-out vs recall grammar (throw → arc → open → burst → full-size exit → ball returns; red beam only on recall), and severity-scaled hit reactions about the blow axis. Project layout gains refs/ and CREDITS.md.
• 3.6.0 — Renamed to Diorama throughout: the playbook, templates and QA docs now call the artifact a diorama. No code behaviour changed.
• 3.5.1 — Camera-scale rule made explicit: subjectScale is a post-fit multiplier (0.70 = 30% smaller linearly), while fillX/fillY stay a fit margin. The camera template now exposes fitDistance and subjectScale; qa/audit.mjs now proves distance ≈ fitDistance / subjectScale when those two fields are exposed, and post.size ≈ CSS × renderScale when the post exposes it. Added the Dust Kings calibration (fit 67.93 → actual 97.05, projected slab 872 → 611 px) and a rule against shrinking the geometry or canvas frame to create margin. PixelPost gains a renderScale argument; Dust Kings renders at 1.25× (buffer 1640 × 950 on a 1312 × 760 CSS canvas) so the smaller diorama keeps its edge detail without changing page size. The resolution section now separates buffer from layout and warns about the frame-rate cost.
• 3.5.0 — Surface/Motion/Event-FX correction release from a truck-diorama postmortem: finish heightfield/slab edges flush (no lip or portal), keep every exiting mover visible until its world bounds clear the slab, never fade a solid hero with material opacity, gate exhaust/steam/dust by authored event windows with the emitter at the physical nozzle, and replace flat untextured halo quads with radial-alpha sprites. New qa/audit.mjs checks flat glows, whole-group fades, early hides, teleports, idle/orphan emitters and paper-margin leaks; shoot, portrait, sweep and strip now fail with a nonzero exit code; QA README documents the optional audit contract. New DESIGN audit sheet; detail.js gains haloPlane/softDiscTexture so a soft light card is the default.
• 3.4.0 — The fragile code is now shipped, not described: poses.js, transfer.js (climb, stand spots, facing), track.js and a stage.js skeleton with a worked actor chain; qa/ as runnable scripts (shoot, portrait, strip, probe, sweep) instead of a checklist; Numbers split into invariants and calibrated values. Water, wake and splash re-verified in verify/water/, which found two real defects: the splash used Math.random (now seeded) and neither effect could be frozen (both now expose reset(); the harness re-simulates from zero and a two-frame diff fell from 334 to 18 pixels). build.mjs writes a favicon stub so the 404 stops polluting the console gate.
• 3.3.0 — Social/life-scene release from the Night Market build: clothed-cast craft (skull/jaw head, hairline, layered garments, hands), carry/handoff and crate-loading rules, scooter/cargo-bike anatomy, two-wheeler mount with hip-Z abduction, service/queue state machine with moving gates, Night Market worked example and fix table, 2x backing/scale-by-camera guidance, empty-paper rule, social verification logs, night/practical/headlight guidance, cutaway and glazing rules, bus/van anatomy, cat/dog quadruped rig and gait, generalised DESIGN.md with Life/Service and Contact/Choreography sheets, new peopleModel-street.js template, scene fast path, and a laundromat/workshop router row.
• 3.2.3 — Hollow-object rule: cannon bores, pipe mouths, chimney flues, lamp chimneys and tunnels need open collars, a recessed dark bore, a back disc and a lip ring. Added 1:1 bore audit and the brass-end-cap pitfall; the Bombard cannon now has an open muzzle instead of a cap.
• 3.2.2 — Fixed cannon ammo station rebuilt as a wall-mounted locker below the deck: shelf, brackets, powder chest, shot tray and hung rammer, outside both yaw sweep and barrel arc. Added bounding-box overlap check to the pivot audit and recorded the wall-locker pattern.
• 3.2.1 — Rotating-assembly parentage rule: only the gun may live under yaw; fixed deck stores go on a static group. Added pivot-parentage strip and acceptance check; cannon keg, shot and rammer moved off the yaw group.
• 3.2.0 — One-prompt commission mode: default commission table, assumption line, ten-scene router, universal four-question generator, bakery worked example, autonomous eight-pass build, cut-count-not-detail rule and one-prompt acceptance; reading order trimmed to the sections needed.
• 3.1.0 — Canonical numbers/camera/light/post/palette contract; field and machine grammar; goal-response vocabulary; FX edge, snap and contact-context rules; crew/defender rule; human death grammar; climb and rotating-emitter rules; expanded DESIGN.md; new detail.js rope, trophy-board and contact-shadow helpers.
• 3.0.0 — Detail Bar, Animation Bar, new-subject intake, reference density, detail recipes, system/combat animation, attack/death audits, beam/artifact triage, detail-and-animation QA, templates/DESIGN.md, templates/detail.js, templates/combat.js.
• 2.1.0 — Combat Readability section; threshold clearing, tower grammar, boss goal contact, death species, standalone String.replace guard.
• 2.0.0 — Palette/post contract, camera solve, cast rig, vehicle/seat transfers, clipping, verification.

Diorama

A playbook and code kit for building small pixel-art dioramas in Three.js.

Pikachu vs Charizard, 45 s  ·  Dust Kings, 38 s  ·  Pool, 26 s  ·  Bank job, 48 s

Four scenes built with this playbook. Click any tile for the full capture.

Install it in one prompt  ·  What is in here  ·  Start a diorama  ·  Verification

A diorama here is a tiny staged scene on a slab: a locked three-quarter camera, a flat cut-out against white paper, a 64 colour palette with ordered dither and an inked contour, and toy-scale people with real joint animation. The subject changes (pool, night market, bank job, arena battle); the slab, the cast and the presentation stay.

Everything is deterministic. The scene is a pure function of t, so any frame can be frozen, screenshotted and compared. A screenshot is evidence, not a lucky capture.

SKILL.md is the whole playbook: it carries a research-first workflow, the look and animation bars, the pipeline, the recipes, the QA harness and the pitfalls, in one self-contained file. Everything else here is copy-in code that supports it.

The scenes

Pikachu vs Charizard is the fight at the top of this page: Leon throws a ball, Charizard bursts out of it and the ball comes back to his hand, four attacks trade across the arena with their own wind-up and hit reactions, Pikachu takes a knockdown, and the red recall beam only appears once Charizard is beaten.

Dust Kings follows one night's billing: cars on the arena floor, the billboard running through LIVE, NEW RECORD and THANK YOU, and a fire that gets away from them.

Pool is a slow afternoon: one swimmer working laps with a wake trailing behind, one standing waist-deep by the ladder, one folding into a dive beside the board, a lifebuoy and a ball left floating, a lifeguard pacing the far edge, and a sunbather who does not move from the towel.

Bank job runs in daylight: a sedan noses into the curb, a group in dark clothes climbs the bank steps and the windows go red behind them, the sedan pulls away, two cruisers arrive and officers fan out across the street, then the street empties again.

Install it

Paste this into an agent that can run shell commands. It asks where to put the folder, downloads the whole repository (playbook, templates, QA harness and every worked example), reads them, and reports what it learned before it builds anything. SKILL.md carries skill frontmatter (name, description, version), so an agent with a skills directory can load it by name later.

Install the Diorama playbook here, then use it to build scenes.

Repo: https://github.com/sloemo01/diorama

1. Ask me where the folder should go before downloading anything,
   and wait for my answer. Propose ~/skills/diorama as the default.
   Do not pick a path silently.
2. Download the whole repository, not just SKILL.md:
     git clone https://github.com/sloemo01/diorama.git "<target>"
   Without git:
     curl -L -o diorama.tar.gz \
       https://github.com/sloemo01/diorama/archive/main.tar.gz
     tar xzf diorama.tar.gz && mv diorama-main "<target>"
3. Prove the install before describing it: SKILL.md, README.md,
   templates/, verify/ and LICENSE at the root, and print the
   commit hash (git -C "<target>" rev-parse --short HEAD) or the
   archive date. If you have no shell or no network, say so and
   stop. If the download failed or a file is missing, say so and
   stop. Never describe this playbook from memory.
4. If you have a skills directory or plugin folder, install it
   there so you can load it by name in later sessions; otherwise
   treat "<target>" as the folder.
5. Read before you build: all of SKILL.md, then
   templates/DESIGN.md, templates/SOURCES.md, templates/CREDITS.md,
   templates/qa/README.md, the header comment of every file in
   templates/, and the worked examples under verify/. SKILL.md is
   the source of truth; the README is only a summary.
6. Report back in this order: install path and commit, the Look
   Contract in one paragraph, the Pipeline as ordered steps, the
   QA scripts and what each one checks, and three rules from
   SKILL.md with the section each came from.
7. Then ask me what the first diorama should be. Do not ask me to
   fill the design sheet. When I give you a subject, research it
   first (frames, assets, motion), fill DESIGN.md from the
   defaults, copy the modules you need into my project instead of
   editing the installed copy, build through the Pipeline, and run
   the QA scripts before you show me anything. Give me the paths
   of the frames you kept and what each one proves.

If two parts of SKILL.md contradict each other, list them before
you build. A successful clone is not an install: 5 and 6 are it.

Needs git, or curl and tar for the fallback. The QA scripts need Node with three, esbuild and playwright-core. The media/ previews are about 20 MB and can be deleted after the clone.

What is in here

Path	What it is
SKILL.md	The whole playbook: research gate, look contract, detail and animation bars, pipeline, recipes, QA, pitfalls. Start here.
templates/	Copy-in modules: palette, post pass, camera, lighting, geometry, props, rig, poses, vehicle transfer, paths, combat, creature, water, effects, build script.
templates/DESIGN.md	The design sheet you fill before modelling.
templates/SOURCES.md	The research log you fill before modelling: query, what was found, decision.
templates/CREDITS.md	The licence ledger for every imported model, clip or texture.
templates/creature.js	Rigged-actor combat: stage-local aiming, bone-space effect anchors, upright billboards, hit severities, send-out geometry.
templates/qa/	Eight verification scripts that check a build against frozen frames and printed numbers, including a per-entity frame recorder.
verify/water/	A worked scene that exercises the water modules, with the screenshots the QA loop produced.
verify/climb/	A unit test for the vehicle transfer maths.
verify/creature-battle/	What a two-actor fight build proved: aiming, effect anchoring, send-out and hit numbers.
media/	The preview GIFs and source captures shown above.

Start a diorama

1. Read SKILL.md: Research Before You Model, One Prompt, One Build, The Look Contract, The Detail Bar, The Animation Bar, Pipeline.
2. Research first. Step the real subject into frames and write its motion grammar down. Walk the sourcing ladder for every hero asset (already on disk, CC0, CC-BY, then hand-build) and record each search in refs/SOURCES.md. Imported assets get a row in CREDITS.md.
3. Copy templates/DESIGN.md into the project as DESIGN.md and fill it. Premise as a verb, cast, systems, five beats with timestamps, detail budget.
4. Copy the modules you need into src/core/ and src/scene/, then a config.js that holds the scene's numbers. verify/water/src/ is the reference layout.
5. Block out in grey at the locked camera before any production pass, then run the pipeline: palette, materials, detail, animation, effects, post.
6. Verify with templates/qa/ before calling it done, and check the research gate in Build And Ship (reference sheets, SOURCES.md, CREDITS.md, per-beat captures).

Research before you model

The playbook opens with four lookups, because a plausible silhouette that matches nothing is the most common way a commission fails:

• Shape. Pull the real thing on video, step it into contact sheets at 8 to 12 fps, read them, and write the grammar down before touching geometry.
• Assets. Check the user's disk, then the CC0 and CC-BY libraries (Quaternius, KayKit, Poly Pizza, Kenney, Sketchfab with the downloadable plus CC0 filter, Smithsonian, Poly Haven, ambientCG, Mixamo and the Quaternius animation library). A rigged download beats four hundred lines of primitives at close range. Licences that are NC, ND, ripped or unstated are a hard stop.
• Motion. Search the verb, not the noun. Count frames at a known fps, convert to seconds, and write wind-up / contact / follow-through / recover before animating.
• Proof. Freeze every beat and compare the capture against the reference frame for that beat.

templates/SOURCES.md and templates/CREDITS.md are the two artifacts that make that research visible in a project, and Build And Ship will not pass wi